We wife and I are somewhat experienced cruisers and like to be a little pampered and be made to feel we are experiencing something upscale.
The ports were all good, the service on board was very good, the overall quality of the ship was fine.
We haven't cruised on one of the large lines in a couple of years, so we could see where there have been cutbacks. These are the little touches which were noticed and appreciated.
Still have old TV's. Bathrooms look worn.
No individual bottle of toilitries.
Overall they are basic and comfortable.