This was my first cruise and I might be overly critical in this review. The ship was dirty, staterooms were horrendous - dirty (mold in the shower), we found a cockroach in the cabinets, and it was extremely smelly, especially in the hallway. It needs some serious stateroom updates, such as carpet and furniture replacement.
Service in the Winjammer Cafe was horrible. The food was mediocre at best. I will say that desserts were great. The menu lacked variety from day to day. Dinner seemed like it was leftovers from lunch plus a couple of additions.
The main dinning room was really good. It looked great and service there was exceptional. You do, however, feel the ship moving a lot in the dinning room. Heard someone say that it was positioned over the engine room.