The Good, Bad and the Ugly about the Carnival Magic: Carnival Magic Cruise Review by houstoncruisers2001

Carnival Magic 2
Member Since 2004
4,280 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

The Good, Bad and the Ugly about the Carnival Magic

Sail Date: January 2012
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Galveston
If the Carnival Magic is the best ship and/or class of ship that Carnival has to offer then they leave a lot to be desired. We were not overly impressed. I'm sure some of that has to do with the fact that we cruised the Oasis of the Seas last year. Although both newer ships for their respective companies, they can not be compared in any fair way. That being said, here is my review of the Magic.

Embarkation was not an issue for us because there was no fog delay on January 15th, 2012. We arrived at the port, walked directly in to the terminal and proceeded straight to the counter. We were on board by 11:30 in the morning and encountered no delays or problems of any kind.

First impressions. Nice atrium upon entering the ship. Atrium bar looked inviting. We headed up to the Lido deck to hit the buffet. The basic buffet was not that good, in fact it was bad. I know, food tastes vary for everyone, but I did hear some complaints right off the bat. We proceeded to More tour the ship after a brief lunch. Pools looked small and very Carnival-like to me. Pool area under the big screen was nice with many different seating options on two levels. The aft pool area seemed like i nice place to hang out too. The Promenade deck, the heart of the ship, was very similar to the Carnival Conquest's promenade. In fact, the ship in general reminded me of the Conquest, only newer with some improvements. Liked the outdoor area along the promenade with the hot tubs and the bar like atmosphere on the port side of the ship.

Dining. Main dining room was a disappointment, mainly with the food. Our service was good, but others have said it was slow. We had a table for 12 at table 768 in the Southern Lights. We choose late seating and our whole table was family. Our headwaiter, Yuni from Bali was great. She worked hard and was very sweet. The food items were hit & miss. I was surprised that the second formal night did not have a better menu. First formal night was lobster and prime rib. Food as a whole just wasn't up to par. Some family members tried the specialty restaurants and both, the steakhouse & Italian place received good reviews. As stated, buffet was not good. Lunch closed at 2:30 in the afternoon so pizza, burger & grill lines were very long for the rest of the afternoon. Food was better at these locations, however.

Shows. Another disappointment. Carnival singers and dancers worked had, but they didn't have much to work with. The show, WIN was lame to say the least. I mean, it was really lame. The illusionist did a great job, even though some of the illusions were pretty basic. At least he kept us entertained. Juggler guy was pretty good at times too. Wife loves the shows and these shows were a huge letdown. On Conquest, for example they were great as they were on most other ships we have been on.

Other entertainment. Disco was fun. It was crowded every night except for the last night. To me, the piano bar singer sounded like a bellowing bull. I've heard much better. The ship's band was pretty good, but I wished they played in the lounge more instead along the promenade walkway. Heard one comedian was good, the other not so good, but I never saw them perform in person.

Cruise staff. Never saw James the cruise director much in person. His staff was doing the usually stuff though. One of his staff members did tell me that he hated his job. which I thought was odd. Service staff around ship seemed unhappy or grumpy, but there were some smiling faces. Coffee bars girls were always nice & friendly, as were every staffer in the Red Frog Pub. Photographers weren't very friendly. Tried to rush you through.

The best. Red Frog Pub. Great place to hang out. Thirsty Frog Red beer was really good. Tasted like Ziegenbock beer for those of you who live in Texas. Get the 101 ounce tube. It's the best deal on the ship. Free shuffle board was fun too in the pub as was trying to get that darn ring on the tree outside the pub. Liked the promenade hot tubs too, they seemed to be the only ones hot and they were generally less crowded. Enjoyed the disco too.

The worst. Being overrun by kids in the pools and hot tubs. Can only imagine what spring break will be like. Many unsupervised kids with no Carnival staff around pool areas, especially aft pool. There needs to be a better adult area for us big kids. Serenity lacked in this area with no pool, lukewarm hot tubs and limited seating.

Disembarking was a disaster due to a major fog delay. It was not Carnival's fault and I think they handled it well on board. Got to use the cabin until well into the afternoon. Had another lunch and they opened the pub for business. Cruise director kept us informed. The problem was once we left the ship. Terminal was a madhouse to say the least. Total nightmare.

Overall, out of 11 cruises I rate this one tenth or eleventh, at or near the bottom. It was my fifth favorite ship out of 6, too. I don't see us cruising Carnival again. I mean, I had fun, but the ship, crew and entertainment underwhelmed us. I know a cruise is different for every person so don't let my negative review damper your upcoming cruise. I hope it is a great cruise. I really do. Less

Published 01/25/12

Cabin review: 8F6438 Balcony

Cabin was nice. Port side, back towards the aft. It was right where the outside promenade deck narrows. No noise in cabin, but on balcony you could hear people talking down near the pub. There are outside places to sit by the pub and late night talkers tend to sit there. Heard complaints from someone in cabin 6422 about Vibes disco being under his room and the vibrations. Also I don't think I'd want a deck 6 cabin along the wide part of the promenade. Have no complaints about our cabin or our cabin steward, Irene.

Read All Balcony (8F) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

Cozumel is Cozumel. We docked at Puerto Maya, but I prefer the other dock with Senor Frogs. We never left the port area while we were there. Hit all the shops, had a lunch at Pancho's Backyard along with some drinks. Also had some drinks at Fat Tuesdays. I know it's Mexico, but a lot of underage kids were getting served. Saw someone buy Patron with a learners permit, not even a drivers license. Oh well.
Read 5492 Cozumel Reviews

We love Grand Cayman and go to Seven Mile Beach every time. I gave the port rating a 4 because of tender troubles once again. We can never seem to get off the ship and the lines to get back on were ridiculous. Not sure what the answer is. Anything, 14 of us got in a van right at the cruise terminal for $3 a person. We were dropped off at Sea Grape Beach along Seven Mile Beach. The water is so beautiful, but it gets deep fast. Very slanted getting in and out too. Great place to spend a couple of hours. The same lady who dropped us off picked us up and then we spent some time shopping before returning to the ship.

We went to Sunset Beach Resort in Montego Bay. We have been there twice before. It's a five minute cab ride from the ship. I give it a 4 rating because it's now $60 per adult and unless you plan on drinking a lot it might not be worth it anymore. I wouldn't stay there, but for a day pass it's ok. It has nice pools, a big hot tub which was very hot and a small water park. Drinks were flowing and my family, many who have not been there before, enjoyed it. Buffet wasn't too good, but the grill had good hamburgers, nachos and stuff. Most of the resort is family friendly, but there is a nude beach section down the beach after a row of bushes and some security guards. Overall, Sunset Beach served its purpose, but hopefully they don't raise their prices any higher.

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Western Caribbean Cruises

Read more Carnival Magic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Magic Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Western Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2004
4,280 Forum Posts
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Skip X

See Carnival Magic deals up to 82% off:

October Deals
Carnival Magic 70% Loved It

7 Day Exotic Western Caribbean
See all Carnival Magic Deals >>