This was my 6th cruise with Norwegian. I have always had nothing but good things to say about the ships, food, staff and activities.
Ship.. big, beautiful and new. BUT not a year round NY ship... We were cold during the parties at H20 and am trying to figure out where they will have those parties in the dead of winter. There is no room inside. Even the music and activities in the Atrium.. it was packed. Could only get a seat if you showed up 45 minutes prior to the start of the show. Even though the ship is larger, the common areas were not. It was just too crowded. From what I have heard, if you sail while school is in session it is a much better experience.
Food.. to my surprise I wasn't happy the first 3 days with the buffet (and I am one to pig out while on vacation). It did get better halfway through our trip.. not sure what happened. We also ate in Taste once, food there was excellent! Didn't get to try any of the other dining rooms. I have 2 small children who don't like to sit still so the buffet is better as we can grab and run.