Shopping for river cruises can be confusing, particularly within the mid-tier price range (which encompasses Avalon, AmaWaterways, Viking and Emerald Waterways). The overall high standards and similar inclusions in this category make the differences negligible, but we've split the hairs for you so you can decide whether AmaWaterways or Avalon Waterways is your best choice.
Prices and Inclusions
Prices on Ama and Avalon are in the same ballpark, with some categories commanding higher prices on one versus another. On a June 2017 seven-night Rhine sailing, for example, the entry price on AmaWaterways for the lowest category cabin is lower than Avalon's, by a few hundred dollars ($2,649 vs. $2,949). But then Ama becomes more expensive, with the suites commanding higher prices than Avalon ($6,598 vs. $4,300).
The inclusions on the two lines are almost identical. Avalon and AmaWaterways both include beer, wine and soft drinks at lunch and dinner; all meals, including alternative dining; Wi-Fi; cultural enrichment; a shore excursion in every port, including some active options; and bikes for use in port. On both lines, you'll pay for gratuities separate from your fare and will have some optional for-fee excursions that you can buy.
Itineraries and Fleet
Both Avalon and AmaWaterways have modern fleets that sail on most of river cruising's major waterways. Avalon has 18 riverboats, including 12 "Suite Ships" in Europe that carry between 128 and 166 passengers. AmaWaterways has its own ships in Europe, each accommodating 164 passengers, as well as charters in Asia and Africa.
Both lines sail the Rhine, Main, Danube, Moselle, Seine and Rhone rivers in Europe, as well as the Mekong in Vietnam and Cambodia and the Irrawaddy in Myanmar (Burma). On the latter itineraries, AmaWaterways charters ships while Avalon owns them.
In addition, AmaWaterways offers cruises on the Douro in Portugal, on the Garonne and Dordogne in Bordeaux and tulip time cruises on the Dutch and Belgium waterways. (While Avalon has offered the latter in the past, none are listed on the website for 2017.) AmaWaterways also has several Africa trips that include a short cruise on the Chobe River.
Avalon offers chartered cruises on China's Yangtze and Egypt's Nile, as well as the Amazon and in the Galapagos Islands (not on a riverboat).
Both lines run Christmas market cruises.
Choose Avalon if you want to book a tour before or after your cruise.
Through Globus, as well as other arms of the company (Cosmos and Monograms), Avalon has the ability to set up seamless pre- and post-cruise tours connected with your river voyage. (While Avalon isn't the only river cruise line that's affiliated with a larger tour operator, the other ones that are -- Scenic, Tauck and Uniworld -- have a more upscale focus, with more inclusions and higher price tags.)
Or if you want consistency in Asian destinations. On Myanmar's (Burma's) Irrawaddy and the Mekong River in Vietnam and Cambodia, the company has smaller versions of its Suite Ships instead of charters, which means the experience is more akin to what you'd find in Europe than with a company that doesn't have its own ships.
Choose AmaWaterways if you like wine or ride bikes.
Both lines have themed cruises. Avalon's special sailings include beer, wine, World War II, classical music, culinary, opera and Jewish heritage. But Ama's dedication to oenophiles has extended to 50 themed sailings in 2018. The line also has a partnership with Backroads, an active touring company, offering cruises on the Rhine and Danube that are centered on biking, hiking and other active pursuits. (While Avalon has an Active Danube itinerary in 2017, it's a sole sailing and not a partnership.)
Or if you have kids. AmaWaterways has teamed up with Adventures by Disney to offer family-friendly river cruises with excursions, meals and activities that are planned for multigenerational travelers. The partnership extends to the ship itself; Adventures by Disney helped designed Ama's newest ships, so there are connecting cabins and staterooms with extra beds.
Both Avalon and AmaWaterways include at least one shore excursion in every port you visit. Excursions are typically guided by local experts who know the port's culture and history well and speak English almost perfectly. Both lines also offer premium excursions, which come at an additional cost. These excursions generally are limited to small groups and take you into smaller venues or provide immersive experiences that expose passengers to a port's culture and tradition on a deeper, often hands-on, level.
Both cruise lines use a QuietVox system during excursions, where the tour guide speaks into a headset while passengers listen on receivers. This allows passengers to go at their own pace while still hearing the guide.
Choose Avalon if you want consistent quality of tour guides.
Your local guide on a river cruise can be a bit of a gamble; the quality can vary, depending on whom the line hires. Because Globus employs guides for its tour business as well as its river cruises, the company is often able to get the best in an area because they can offer them the most consistent employment.
Choose AmaWaterways if you want active choices in all ports.
Although Avalon has added an Active Discoveries Danube itinerary to its sailings in 2017 (and a Rhine option is expected in 2018), AmaWaterways makes a point of having three activity levels -- active, general and gentle -- in all of its ports. Most passengers go with the general offering, which usually combines tour buses, some walking and guided exploration of the top sites. Gentle tours are designed for those who need a slower pace or have mobility issues. These tours involve little walking, and destinations are mostly seen by bus or other vehicles. Active tours will go faster and might include stairs, a hike or a guided bike ride.
Enrichment and Entertainment
Both Avalon and AmaWaterways have enrichment activities and port talks that focus on the destinations visited. On either cruise, you might spend an afternoon sampling Austrian wine while your vessel sails on the Danube. Or you might hear a folk music ensemble one evening while docked. Both lines have small dance floors in their lounges, although whether or not they'll be used depends on the passengers. Avalon has the addition of karaoke and a movie night once per cruise.
Both Avalon and AmaWaterways have well-designed cabins, particularly on the upper decks.
On its Suite Ships, Avalon rejiggered most of the cabins (called Panorama Suites) to give them something unique within river cruising: beds that face the water, not the wall. To complement the view, the line decided to go with sliding-glass doors that open the full length of the room, creating an extensive open French balcony. It makes a difference in the size of the room, and is particularly perfect during the shoulder seasons when you won't be on your balcony as much.
The cabins on AmaWaterways' European ships also have a unique approach to outdoor space. "Twin balconies" divide the wall facing outside into two sections. One is a glass door that becomes a French balcony, while the other opens up into a small outdoor balcony large enough for two chairs. It's a good compromise for people who absolutely feel that they want a place to sit outside in their own room.
On the lower "aquarium class" level, Avalon's cabins are slightly bigger than Ama's, at 172 square feet compared to 160 square feet. Twin balcony cabins on AmaWaterways range from 210 to 235 square feet; four suites on each ship measure 300 square feet. That's pretty close to Avalon's boats where Panorama Suites are 200 square feet, and Royal suites (two per ship) are 300 square feet. Neither line has true suites, in the sense that living and bedroom space are divided.
Choose AmaWaterways if you want cabins for singles or families.
Several of AmaWaterways' ships feature cabins for single travelers. Each of these 140-square-foot cabins features a twin bed and space for one, perfect for solo cruisers. Two Ama ships -- AmaViola and AmaStella -- as well as new-for-2017 AmaKristina also include several cabins that can accommodate three people (with a king-sized bed along with a chair that converts into a twin bed). AmaViola, AmaStella and AmaKristina also feature a number of connecting cabins, designed with families in mind.
Choose Avalon if you don't need outdoor space.
Because they have French balconies instead of outdoor space, the 200-square-foot Panorama cabins on Avalon's Suite Ships feel bigger than most river cruise cabins. Avalon's bathrooms also seem larger, due to the cabin's configuration at a slight angle (to give cruisers that river view mentioned earlier). Overall, stateroom space seems better used on Avalon than Ama.
While the quality of food is subjective, both AmaWaterways and Avalon make sure that cruise passengers have a wide variety of dishes, both familiar and local to the region, at breakfast, lunch and dinner. Both cruise lines serve buffets at breakfast and lunch, as well as a selection of made-to-order items. Waiter-served dinners are usually at 7 p.m., and you can sit wherever you want, although tables for two are hard to come by on both ships. The meal is a four-course affair; five if it's a special captain's dinner. Both lines also have alternative light dining at breakfast and lunch. Wine, beer and soda are available at lunch and dinner on both lines; on Ama, you'll also find sparkling wine in the morning if you're craving a mimosa.
Both Ama and Avalon pay scrupulous attention to passengers' dietary needs. Both lines mark allergens on their menus and both offer gluten-free pastas, breads and entrees. Avalon has signed a partnership with the Wrenkh brothers, noted Austrian chefs, who specialize in vegetarian and vegan dishes, to add special dishes to the menus in 2017, but you'll also find healthy options marked on Ama too.
Perhaps the biggest difference between the two lines is that on some of its ships, AmaWaterways has a space set aside for an alternative restaurant on the top deck, aft. (On Avalon, this space is an enclosed glass lounge.) The Chef's Table on Ama has a set multicourse menu with wine pairings that you're allowed to book for free once per cruise.
Avalon also has a tasting menu with wine pairings, held several times per cruise. The meal has 15 courses (they are small) and is held in the ship's main lounge. It almost always reflects regional dishes.
Both lines have several Captain's dinners during the cruise that add extra courses and usually free hors d'oeuvres during that night's cocktail hour. In addition, Ama is a member of the French gastronomic society, Chaine des Rotisseurs; there's a French dinner with wines from that country served for everyone in the main dining room once per cruise.
Cruises on both Avalon and AmaWaterways are designed to be destination intensive, which means you won't find a lot of extras such as casinos. Both ships have small fitness rooms with treadmills, recumbent bikes or elliptical machines and free weights.
On Avalon, Suite Ships also have a salon for hair services and manicures. AmaWaterways boats feature small (one-room) spas, where moderately priced massages are offered, and a small salon. Both ships also have bikes onboard to use in port.
Choose AmaWaterways if you want a pool.
On the top deck on some of its ships, AmaWaterways has heated swimming pools with swim-up bars that are surprisingly large for a river line. Pools feature underwater stools so passengers can sit at the bar and watch the scenery go by.
Choose Avalon if you want an indoor lounge away from the crowd.
Because Avalon doesn't have a separate space set aside for its alternative restaurant, there's a lovely glass-enclosed spot aft where you can read, check the internet on your device or simply grab a coffee and cookie and watch the world go by.
Both Avalon and AmaWaterways offer excellent river cruises for the price; it's hard to go wrong with either one and the differences between them are slight. The best way to decide is to look at the specific itinerary and compare ports and rates.