Overall, I would give this ship a C+. As a hotel, it gets an A. The accommodations were elegant and spacious (I had a junior suite), thoughtfully designed, and convenient; the service was friendly and efficient. The only annoyance was the fact that this ship holds so many people that the wait for the elevators was endless. I got lots of exercise sprinting up and down the stairs. There were lots of things to keep you occupied, although most catered to young adults. The pools (3) were small, but they never felt crowded. There were sufficient deck chairs, although the ones in the sun were always occupied. The gym was very nice.
The entertainment on board was spectacular. I was very pleasantly surprised, and we went every night.
Now for the food. I was very disappointed. Everyone had told me how great the food on RCI is. Well, maybe I picked the wrong boat, but the food was so-so at best--with the exception of Portofino, the "speciality" restaurant for which you pay an additional $20 per person. That food was superb. Too bad about the rest of the food.