Carnival Freedom - Eastern Caribbean: Carnival Freedom Cruise Review by SaucyPirateWench

Carnival Freedom 5
Member Since 2010
49 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

Carnival Freedom - Eastern Caribbean

Sail Date: September 2010
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: Fort Lauderdale (Port Everglades)
We (Kimberly 43, Toby 37, Luke 18 & Jackson 7) returned a few days ago from the 8 day Eastern Caribbean itinerary for the Carnival Freedom. First, let me say that I have never been on another cruise line, so my observations are somewhat limited and have no comparison. I am someone that can be very easy to please, or easily pissed off, given my mood. I've been 'well off' and I've been dirt poor, so I can usually roll with the punches and deal with most things...except rudeness. You've been warned ;)

THE TRIP: We flew in from Atlanta to Ft. Lauderdale on Friday night in the rain. Hurricanes and tropical storms had been abuzz for weeks, threatening to ruin our trip, so I was not pleased...but even moi cannot change the weather. We had booked our hotel through Expedia, which has always been fine. We stayed at the Hampton Inn Airport North in Ft. Lauderdale...being that our cruise left on September 11th I didn't want to fly in the morning of and have any crazies pull More something that shut any air travel down. We called the hotel for our *FREE* shuttle and waited 45 minutes for the 15 minute the rain. But hey, it was free. The hotel was the nicest 2 1/2 star I've seen...clean, updated and comfy bed, *FREE* hot breakfast buffet, then the *FREE* shuttle to Port Everglades. I had read that the shuttle was overcrowded...we are not ones that have to be on the ship asap, so we waited til 1:30, extended our noon checkout to 1:00 and watched some TV while we enjoyed the spacious lobby area. All went smoothly, never waited more than a few minutes at embarkation...took a pic and boarded the ship.

THE SHIP: We immediately noticed the decor (and I use that word lightly). It's just pattern overload! There's not a square inch of surface on that ship that is untouched, unadorned in some way. I called it "My Big Fat Greek Wedding meets Jersey Shore". The orange, lime and purple tiger stripped paneling is the worst, and it's everywhere. After a while you make a game of seeing how many different patterns you can find in any given area. I can't say it grew on us...but cruise ship decor is never subdued, right? The ship was very clean, though...and that matters more to me than the ugly decor. The layout always seems to take some getting used to. We always find our favorite places and figure out the easiest way to get there. Same as on other ships, not really worse, as I have read in reviews. There were many different options for food, swimming, sun bathing, reading in quiet, etc. We never had trouble finding a chaise...but the pools got overcrowded at times, and lines at the Lido deck were as we usually find...not too bad and not worth complaining about...remember you are on a boat with 2973 other passengers and 1150 crew members, they all get hungry at lunch time just like you do. Serenity deck is also too crowded, but when it's not and that hammock becomes free...there's nothing better than laying next to the husband swinging in the breeze with the Caribbean Sea as a backdrop. Camp Carnival was the absolute best! My 7 yr old son loved it, loved the companionship of the kids and felt like it was his vacation, too and not just being dragged along with the grown ups. We hit the casino once, I'm one of those prudes that's very intolerant to cigarette smoke, so bars and casinos gross me out.

THE SERVICE: Our room was Main Deck room 2330. Ourcabin steward (Eko) was very nice to us, learned our names and when he could get in (18 yr old was up all night and slept all day) spruced the room up nicely. I have a theory about hotel/motel/cruise ship rooms...whether it's the Ritz Carlton or the Motel's a bed and bath that a stranger used directly before's all yuk to me. Hairs, smells etc. all linger no matter what. What matters is the comfort of the bed and linens, and this is where my only MAJOR complaint on this trip comes in. Where was our Carnival Comfort Bed?? Not in our room, that's for sure. The beds and bunks were all in major need of an updating in mattress and linens. Pillowcases had the little "pills" on them from wear and age, the mattresses were some of the most uncomfortable I've EVER slept says a lot when a 7 yr old complains of a sore back in the morning. I hope this room gets a make over, STAT! It was a cheaper interior room, traveling with 2 kids this time I figured a romantic balcony or even window would be a waste. I'd rather spend the $$ on shore trips and plane travel for 4. I made the right decision. I'll save the romantic view for my 10th anniversary in March. Dinner service was fine, we did Your Time Dining...I'll never go back to early/late dining. Wait staff was friendly and competent. I'm not the type to complain about service unless it's horrible...our was fine. We never waited for a table, as I've read here. Food was all good. Best was Lasagna Bolognese (sp?) Had steak many nights, all tender and tasty. Only whiny moments: warm chocolate melting cake was a little too done in the center most nights and brie was not to my sons liking. We don't really have sophisticated pallets and are not wine drinkers. I never understand when people complain about cruise ship food...this isn't Maxim's in's mass produced food. If you don't like something, order something else.

THE STAFF: Cruise director seems nice and friendly, never had a problem with anyone but one girl at guest services. We don't normally do credit, but one must have a credit card to setup sail & sign, so I asked ahead to make sure that we could change it to cash once on board...of course by the 2nd morning they charged our gratuities (which I hate...what's to motivate good service if they know they are already getting a full tip?) so I asked them to be removed and she spoke to me as if I were mentally challenged. Then found out the hold on the credit card wouldn't be removed till back in the States...I do not like the whole sail & sign business. Give me a room key card to get on and off the ship...if I want to shop or gamble or drink on board, then I'll set one up...don't automatically assume I'll be shopping...and why not just allow cash purchases? I know most love the s&s card system, but the only way it works for us is to remove the early tip charges, set up a cash account and pay as you go on your cash...I know cash is an antiquated way of commerce in 21st century life, but we prefer it. One staffer out right lied to us at the excursion desk...told us the only way to see the El Morro Fortress in San Juan was to take their tour, cause it closed at 3pm. I should have investigated it online better before departing but this was a last minute decision so we just went with it. Well...the tour did not tour the Fort, only went by it. I could have done that for free instead of $49.99 per person. If your job is the excursions desk operator...don't lie to people, tell them the real deal and let them decide. Because of this I'll never book another shore excursion on board again. Besides those two people, we never encountered rudeness. I've read that some said the crew on this ship were grouchy. I don't expect butt kissing, just serve me food, clean my room, etc. I think as with most things in life, people spend a little money on their cruise fare and expect to be treated like the Queen...come on, these people work hard and everyone has a bad day sometimes. Camp Carnival deserves the highest praise. Our 7 yr old was treated very well there and we begged to go back daily...that says it all. Less

Published 09/27/10
1 Helpful Vote

Cabin review: 4C2330 Interior

Smallish closets for 4 people, lumpy hard beds, quiet, easy mid ship location.

Read All Interior (4C) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

I had done some internet research about Antigua and learned about their public buses. We used the directions another Cruise Critic member had posted, we took the 10 minute walk past the MOST aggressive cabbies on the planet to the 'bus station', found the #22 bus and boarded. The drivers do wait til the vans are mostly full before leaving, but we only waited 20 minutes or so, then off on a high speed, left side drive of your life! We were the only "tourists" on this van...but I love to travel to experience other cultures, not just the sanitized versions. We passed some real poverty...sad, but a part of life. We never felt insecure, and enjoyed the natural beauty of this Island of 365 Beaches. The 25 minute ride cost $4 for the 3 of us...the cabbies quoted us $25 each way!! We went to Valley Church Beach...the most beautiful beach we've seen in our travels, ranks up there with Magens Bay of 10 yrs ago. The Nest Beach Bar is the only game in town there...and a cheeseburger, fries and 2 can cokes will set you back $16.65 plus tip...but the chaise and an umbrella were negotiated to $10 for the day, and the jet skis started at $50 per half hour then also negotiated to $25. All very friendly people, only one lady and one man selling their instruments and jewelry...not pushy at all. When our day here was over we walked the short dirt path back to the road and waited an astonishing 5 seconds for the bus! Hopped on and were back in port then back to the of our favorite shore excursions, and the cheapest! No Worries, Mon!

Read 1191 Antigua Reviews

We've been to Nassau before, and getting here at Noon didn't leave time for Atlantis, so we walked around a little, then back on board.

Read 5019 Nassau Reviews

We've been here before. I wished we could have enjoyed the day more...we arrived at 5pm, so excursions are limited. We took the 'sunset walking tour' because we had been told we'd visit the El Morro Fortress. We walked by it...I could have done that alone. It was not worth the $152 for the 4 of us. Old San Juan is a beautiful old city. With our 7 yr old we were also limited to nightlife options...the CVS drugstore was helpful!

Read 2947 San Juan Reviews

We pre-booked a day sail with New Horizons. Great internet deal! Do your homework and save money and get MUCH better excursions than are offered on board. We sailed from Sapphire Marina to St. John...had some beach time and snorkeling, a wonderful lunch, many, many painkillers, beers, cokes and a friendly, funny crew and met some nice people, as well! 7 hours of beauty, fun and swimming with a 4 ft long Barracuda named Barry. The only downside was the $80 plus tip taxi ride from the cruise port to the Marina about 15 minutes away. We grabbed the "gov't sanctioned" taxi right off the pier and had no negotiation room for the fare...but we were pressed for time, and chalked it up as a live and learn!

Read 3995 St. Thomas Reviews

We were wore out and spent out, so we skipped the beaches and the famous Virgin Gorda Baths this trip. Our ship departed at 3:30, so we figured we'd save that for the next time around. We bought t shirts and bracelets, etc. then walked along the waterfront. We found a shop with hand made items from the Island's Seniors and mentally handicapped. I got a cute handmade shell Christmas ornament for $4, thought it was sweet! We had wanted to rent a car here, but the fast pace of traffic and left hand driving in the Islands scared my out of it. There were plenty of open air buses for $15 per person for Island tour...but the 7yr old was tired and hot, so we went back early and enjoyed the ship.

Read 1239 Tortola Reviews

Compare Prices on Carnival Freedom Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Read more Carnival Freedom cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Freedom Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Freedom Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2010
49 Forum Posts
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Carnival Freedom deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Carnival Freedom 77% Loved It

7 Day Eastern Caribbean
See all Carnival Freedom Deals >>