A very bad experience that has made us think we might never cruise again.
First, the positives:
Staff, especially cabin stewards, were cheerful and helpful. Entertainment was good; 'Step One' dancers were excellent (but pure dance shows eventually wear thin) and the 'Lincoln Center Stage' musicians were first class, although sadly they have been given a poor venue that is open to the corridor.
See above. VB was our booked grade but we ended up being downgraded to VD.