• Write a Review
  • Boards
  • Log In
Marina Cruise Review
4.5 / 5.0
Cruise Critic Editor Rating
713 Reviews

I love it - of course there is no such thing as perfection :)

Marina Cruise Review by call-of-the-sea

2 people found this helpful
Trip Details
  • Sail Date: Dec 2016
  • Destination: South America
  • Cabin Type: Penthouse Suite

This is my second cruise on Oceania, the first one was on Riveira, in the Med. Marina is almost the same as Riveira,with very small differences. On both cruises we booked Penthouse 1 (PH1) cabin and have been very very satisfied. Both ships are in very good shape, nicely apppointed, decorated, pleasant and smart but not OTT (over the top). Everything is smart causal, including the required attire and that suits us very well. Captain, crew and staff are well trained and very nice in a relaxed way. 99% are doing their best to please the guests. Very high staff to guest ratio.

Oceania's cruises are for middle-aged and older people (though we have a few families and younger couples now) and everything is set up accordingly. There is entertainment but not around the clock. A lot of music: all afternoon, evening and up to midnight there is some music somewhere on the ship (from string quartett to rock-and-roll) but not incessantly. Various musicians move around the ship in various lounges and bars.

Wonderful band and singer every night up top on level 15 (Horizons bar and lounge) for dancing. Bound to bring even the shy to the dance floor with a superb mixture of various types of dance music for everyone.

Sound proofing is excellent, the noise never penetrates other areas, there are always plenty places to relax, read, take a nap in without much disturbance. Excellent and beautiful library with plenty books.

Every night one hour of show, nice and fun but, again, not too much.

Some very good lectures, generally two lecturers talking about the area we are in or will be in; history, geology, marine life, whatever. We had a superb lecturer, Terry Bishop, from the UK. He is just unique, professional and amazing in every way. He also entertains and his muisc and singing is absolutely worth listening to.

The other lecturer, John Freedman is also very knowledgeable but he tends to cram too much into his 45 minutes talks and as a result one can't retain anything. His talks are OTT for even academics or people with various university degrees. He wanders about in various subjects, geograhic areas and among various people in history and only he can see the connections :). The lectures can be later listened to on a TV channel.

The South Atlantic and South Pacific are not easy waters; often with a lot of wind and swell. So I recommend everybody to bring Sea Bands and sea sickness pills and not to expect a smooth ride. Also important to book an outside cabin midship and on one of the lower decks. That reduces the movement significantly. Expect more movement up top and in the bow, where Horizons is (it is easy to dance when the floor moves! :D).

It is summer in South America now but South of Puerto Madryn on the Atlantic side and Valparaiso on the Pacific side it is windy, cool and often rainy. Part of the deal.

There are small niggles like I have had lots of frustration with obtaining gluten free bread in the normal timescale of dinner and not being able to get lactose free yoghurt but the only real issue is the very poor value for money of excursions. I understand this is a problem on every cruise with every cruise liner so I don't want to make a big deal of it. Just remember not to book too many excursions via the ship but rather reserach the ports and area on the net before the cruise and make private arrangements. Often it is best just to disembark and find a taxi or van with driver/guide - they ususally queue up for your business where you go ashore. Much cheaper, much better, flexible and adaptable to your needs and wishes.

We had two excellent excursions via Oceania. One was in Puerto Arenas, the sheep farm excursion. Estanzia Fitz Roy is much more than just a sheep farm, it is quirky, wonderful collection of hundreds (or perhaps thousands) of old items and offers buildings/structures that make you smile and feel good in. it is run by an extended family, who are all happy there - and you can feel it. We also happened to have a very good guide there.

The other excellent excursion was to Santiago (from the port of Valparaiso) with a superb guide called Maximo. Very good English, lots of relevant info, good sense of humour, took wonderful care of us. Santiago is interesting and manageable in a few hours.

We are now on the second leg of our booking: a second cruise from Valaparaiso to Miami. If you book to cruises back to back it is imprtant to book very early so you can have the same cabin for both as to not have to move.

I had a nasty surprise when I had a letter in the cabin, with just 24 hours notice, that the one tour I booked and was really looking forward to, a trip from the port of Coquimbo, Chile to a world famous observatory (Tololo) was cancelled, due to lack of interest. I wanted to quickly arrange a private visit but as it was embarkation day for the second cruise for most of the day I couldn't talk to anybody at the excursions desk or to the concierge. I tried to arrange something on the net and found out that Tololo only accepts visitors on Saturdays. As the tour was planned for Friday, it would never have been possible anyway. It is a shame that Oceania staff lied rather than apologise for a mix-up.

It is a great improvement that you can now have internet on board, free if you book into a more expensive cabin or via various packages. Beware though, the band width and speed, or even availability is variable to say the least. It is hardly ever sufficient to talk on Skype or WhatsApp, often impossible to upload photos but most of the time enough for email. Easiest times to use seem to be when staff are not on it : 6-10 am and 7-11 pm.

Food is great on Oceania - too good for your waistline! I defy anybody not to find not to enjoy it. So varied, so manay different restaurants, so obliging with any special wishes (apart from good quality gluten free bread :) ) that everybody is bound to find gastronomic enjoyment.

There are many Americans on board (a bit too many for our liking,as Europeans) and lots of Canadians. There are some Europeans but not as many I would wish for. (I still count British as Europeans, Brexit hasn't happened yet :D).

It is a bit tiring when they tell me that I have a lovely English accent and I have to tell them that one can't have an English accent in English - they have an American accent :).

All in all, great experience - go for it!


call-of-the-sea's Full Rating Summary
Cabin
Onboard Experience
Enrichment Activities
Value For Money
Embarkation
Dining
Public Rooms
Entertainment
Fitness & Recreation
Shore Excursions
Service
Sign Up for Price Drop Alerts
Get tomorrow's price drops
250,000+ people have entered their email
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Cabin Review

Penthouse Suite
Cabin PH1 10047

Simply wonderful! Walk in wardrobe (huge), very big and superb bathroom with full size bath and great shower cubicle. Nice big room with slightly seperate area with openable sofa bed, two seating areas, one with high table for meals and one with coffee table. Vanity unit, desk, curtesy laptop, fridge, 110 and 220V sockets (US and European type), lots of good lighting, big mirrors, loads of drawers and bedside cabinet space, nice balcony with comfy loungers with cushions .... everything you would want and more. Buler service comes with the cabin.


Port & Shore Excursion Reviews

Stanley

For me the Falkland Island were the highlight of the cruise. We managed to get ashore (due to weather and swell it is not always possible, it being a tendering port) and found quite a few locals offering tours. In the information centre we picked up an elderly local chap, he took us 2 and another couple with two children on a tour by his 4x4 to see some nature, penguins, birds etc. It was great, leasurely, easy and cheap. We paid US$ 90 for the two of us. Returning from there we had a drink and fish and chips (excellent) in the local pub, talked to people there. Then we walked along the sea front, saw everything worthwhile by ourselves and on the way back to the port we went to the museum too that is not cheap at (I think) £12, but very interesting, absolutely recommended. It made a great day.

Tierra del Fuego National Park

It was actually interesting and saw many penguins but there were too many buses and people, that spoilt the experience a bit.

View All 94 Tierra del Fuego National Park Reviews
Montevideo

We took a private Jewish and city tour by Fanny Margolis (nfirst@netgate.com.uy) - fantastic.

Highly recommended.

Described in my cruise review. Brilliant place.

View All undefined undefined Reviews
Petrohue Falls

The Falls are very nice and Puerta Varas quite enjoyable. Guide average.

View All 36 Petrohue Falls Reviews
Santiago City Tour

Described in my cruise review. Excellent guide.

View All 22 Santiago City Tour Reviews
Buenos Aires

We spent 5 days in BA prior to the cruise. Nice city but almost unbearable trraffic due to demonstrations and strike every day (literally). So beware. Some of our party actauuly had to abandon a private tour because we stood in traffic for hours.

On the cruise, later, I talked to a couple who spent the day of embarkation at BA airport, with thousands of other people, stuck due to the transport strike. Their aircraft was allowed to land but they couldn't get their luggage, nor a sip of water for many hours. People eventually rioted, broke a door down and tried to get their luggage that stood on the tarmac. Police was called in. Dreadful experience.

If your cruise starts in BA, fly in at least 3 days before, look at the city, take in a great tango show and get to the terminal well in time.


Previous ReviewNext Review
call-of-the-sea
1 Reviews Written
2 Helpful Votes
Never Miss a Deal!
Subscribe and Save
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

More Oceania Marina Reviews





Want to cruise smarter?
Get expert advice, insider tips and more.
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.