First time MSC-cruiser. American. Travelled with 24 of my family members, June 11-18, 2016. Ocho Rios, Cayman/Georgetown, Cozumel, Nassau. Have travelled on +/- 6 other cruises, on other lines. Quick review:
Embarkation and Debarkation: Great, quick, very smooth. Amazingly smooth.
Overall food was good—not as much variety as other cruise lines. (I’m guessing many of the Americans that have travelled on MSC don’t care for the smaller portion sizes).
Large cabin, right off elevator bank. Never felt ship movement and never any noise. I'd stay in this cabin again.