My wife, son and I sailed on the February 14, 2015 Reflection cruise out of Miami, visiting San Juan, St. Thomas and St. Maarten.
Overall, I give the cruise very high marks. Among other things, I concur with other reviewers who have given the ship solid reviews for its modern/chic style, cleanliness and a universally friendly and outgoing crew.
The entertainment was also better than what I can remember from past cruises/other cruise lines, especially the comedians. The Beatles cover band -- while a little hokey -- was talented and popular with passengers. And the 'Momentum' production put on by the ship's cast was entertaining and superior to their other productions.
The cabin was on the smallish size. Also we experienced much noise, perhaps due in part to the proximity of the cabin to the nearby elevators. Although the soundproofing on the ship seems to be state-of-the-art, the ship was sailing at fully capacity, with a lots of activity day and night. And no amount of soundproofing was going to keep noise out from the active adjacent cabins, etc. We are not light sleepers, but the noise regrettably affected our sleep. Maybe were just getting crankier as we get older?