Wouldn't sail Freedom again, but would sail Carnival again: Carnival Freedom Cruise Review by jessi2913

Carnival Freedom 4
Member Since 2013

Overall Member Rating

Wouldn't sail Freedom again, but would sail Carnival again

Sail Date: January 2013
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: Fort Lauderdale (Port Everglades)
Based on reviews I read here, I pre-booked parking at Park n Go. Great location to the port, and easy to find, even though the 595 was under heavy construction. It was affordable and after our trip they gave us water bottles as we pulled out to leave - nice touch.

The boarding process went very quickly - no lines. We even missed the "boarding photos" which was fine. We just made the lunch buffet on the Lido deck.

Rooms were ready and luggage was delivered by the time we got back from Muster. Rooms were clean and the stewards were always responsive and helpful.

Ship had very strange (UGLY) decor. Very gaudy and not at all relaxing. The worst might have been the scary statue of liberty floating heads in the Lido restaurant. Or maybe the horrible fake orange/black wood grain paneling. Or maybe the awful, awful fake red/black snake skin wallpaper in the Posh dining room. Every room had a different theme and every room was ugly.

The layout of the More ship was awkward - with the Posh & Chic dining rooms closing off 1/2 the ship - often you had to go up/down floors to get forward or aft.

The food in the Posh was so-so, steak was not good quality, the cold soups all tasted liked smoothies and the seafood was meh. The service was exceptional. The vegetarian options were sparse - but our picky vegetarian made due and our service team worked very hard to accommodate her. Food in Lido was pretty good. We enjoyed the Tandoor and the Wok a lot.

We went to one show - a Beatles review - it was odd. Very sexy costumes and dancing. But the singing was okay. We also enjoyed one night in the comedy club.

Had two appointments in the spa, Mother/Daughter pedicure and a deep tissue massage. The pedicure was fine. The massage was okay - the treatment room was way too small. The spa was not relaxing. The atmosphere was stark and shiny - trying to be cutting edge with bad euro-pop music and hard edges.

We participated in many trivia's and other inside activities - they were fun and well run. The entertainment staff was friendly and funny.

Our favorite thing to do was to sit in the hot tub after dinner and watch the 10pm movie on the big screen on the lido deck. Ice Cream, popcorn, pina coladas, and movies - it was awesome.

Getting off the boat took forever due to some issues with customs. Many people missed their flights.

Overall a great trip. We would book Carnival again - just for the affordable cost alone, especially if we were taking the kids. I wouldn't go on the Freedom again, it was so ugly, I couldn't stand it. Less

Published 02/08/13

Cabin review: 5A

Port and Shore Excursions

We negotiated a tour with a driver ($20/head) and the tour was nice. This island was gorgeous. We had a recommendation to go to Jolly Beach and that was awesome. I would highly recommend Jolly Bay/Beach. The tour was 2 hours and we had the driver come back after 2.5 hours on the beach. There was food, beer and trinkets available + jet skis, catamarans and other beach amenities available to rent. (Chairs & umbrellas) the beach was stunning, the water perfect and not too crowded.
Read 1191 Antigua Reviews

We stayed on the ship (late docking 1pm) until about 3 and enjoyed having the whole ship to ourselves. We only did some shopping right near the port. We stopped and ate at a little shop called ChopStix and the food was reasonable and tasty. We had no interest in the crazy overpriced excursions to Atlantis - from every review I read here it sounded like a rip-off.
Read 5021 Nassau Reviews

We negotiated a tour with a driver (Bernard's was the tour co). The tour was good. We ate at Jenn's Deli - good food - with affordable prices. We aren't really shoppers so none of the jewelry places or high end shops appealed. The little market was nice, the vendors were not too pushy or overwhelming. $25/head for 2.5 hours. There was a push by taxi drivers, tour guides etc to go to Magnens Beach, but we had read here that there was a jellyfish issue and the beach was deserted. We were glad we hadn't paid $100 for a taxi ride to a beach we couldn't use. We stopped at Sapphire beach and it was very pretty.
Read 3995 St. Thomas Reviews

This port was why we chose this cruise itinerary. We had been here in 2009. We arranged for a taxi ride to Brewer's Bay ($16/head) and paid $10 each for snorkel equip from Nicoles. The gear was worse for the wear but did okay. The snorkeling was not as good as it was in 2009. The coral was mostly dead and the fish were few & far between but it is still a great beach. The surf shack - Nicoles has $3 Red Stripes and good burgers/fries. They also rent chairs. Very laid back. Very nice people. Beach is not huge and could fill up if you weren't there first thing. Little shopping area near the port was bad - bad selection, cramped and packed.
Read 1239 Tortola Reviews

Compare Prices on Carnival Freedom Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Read more Carnival Freedom cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Freedom Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Freedom Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2013
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Carnival Freedom deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Carnival Freedom 77% Loved It

7 Day Eastern Caribbean
See all Carnival Freedom Deals >>