We chose RCL Oasis because we wanted to experience the large shipliner and all its amenities. The public spaces are beautiful and generally well kept. The Balcony cabins are very small compared to balcony rooms on any other ship. However our Accessible Family Balcony had everything plus more. This room rocked and made our trip expereince wonderful. At Labadee they even provide wheelchairs for free that can be pushed on sand and into the ocean. This is the most accessible cruise ship we have found and for that reason we would definitely cruise again with RCL on their newer ships. This is the only ship we have been on in recent years that still serves lobster in it's main dining room experience. Dining on RCL is top notch with excellent food and service. If you are a foody like me ...unless your wanting a discount cruise expereince...to save money ...go with RCL. At least on their newer ships dining is very good! Buffet food poor!
As far as RCL crown membership experience...its pathetic compared to other cruise lines.
As far as accessibility RCL outshines all other lines in our experience. However cabins are in serious need of updating on this ship. Dirty and worn!