Subscribe today
Get Cruise Critic in your inbox
Your Ultimate Cruise Guide

Carnival Magic Cruise Review by Techman123: Nice Ship - but some crowding issues


Techman123
1 Review
Member Since 2012
0 Posts

Member Rating

Cabin 5.0
Dining 3.0
Embarkation 4.0
Enrichment Activities 3.0
Entertainment 3.0
Family & Children Not Rated
Fitness & Recreation 5.0
Public Rooms 5.0
Rates 4.0
Service 4.0
Shore Excursions 4.0
Value for Money 4.0

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Bahamas Cruises

Nice Ship - but some crowding issues

Sail Date: January 2012
Destination: Bahamas
Embarkation: Galveston

After sailing the Conquest out of Galveston for the past 4-5 year, we were excited to have a new ship coming to Texas.

The ship was late getting into port, so things were a mess at the terminal. We were really glad to have the VIP boarding (10 previous cruises with Carnival).

The ship is a really nice ship. With the name "Magic" I was expecting it to be a bit gaudy, but it was really nice. The outdoor areas are good, but it was kinda cool this week, so not many folks were hanging out at the pools. My son and I really enjoyed the ropes course.

The room was pretty typical, but we did have a "Cove Balcony" room which was pretty neat. These are balcony rooms down on the 2nd deck. Very close to the water. They do have an outer water tight door that I guess they close in high seas, but we never had to close it even though it got pretty rough one night.

The only issue we had with our room was the next door neighbors going out on their balcony at 6am More each morning and letting the door slam. I guess the 2 folks in that room would each go out once. Person 1 out... BAM, Person 2 out... BAM. Person 1 back in..BAM... Person 2 in ...BAM. We usually had at least 4 slams each morning. This was pretty annoying as the balcony door is right next to where the head of our bed was.

SHOWS: We were pretty impressed with the opening show (70s). After seeing "Point and Click" on the Conquest 3-4 times it was a nice change. As the cruise wore on, we were less impressed. There were major crowding issues, as the showroom is just not big enough to accommodate the number of passengers on the ship. If you did not get to the showroom early, you might not even get in.

GAMES: We love to play the trivia and beanbag games. Unfortunately, the lounge that they hold these in is a central walk thru point, so there were issues with noise and crowds. The entertainment staff was very competent, and ran things well.

Dining: The Prime Steakhouse is fantastic. I highly recommend it. (hint - if you go on the first night, they get out a free bottle of wine.) We always do the Steakhouse the first night.

In the main dining room, the food was was pretty typical Carnival fare. Overall pretty good, with a few standouts, and a few misses. However, I think once again this ship is suffering with size issues, as the service was really slow. We often waited 10-20 minutes between courses. Just sitting there with an empty plate.

Overall - While I would say this was an overall good cruise experience, we have had better. We did the Carnival Spirit last January down to Baja. It had all the positives of this cruise, with none of the negatives. I think they need to work out some timing issues with the crowds. Not sure how, but I waited in more lines on this cruise than on any other cruise. Less


Read more Carnival Magic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic's Carnival Magic Review >>

Cabin review: Carnival Magic Balcony Main 2294

The room was pretty typical, but we did have a "Cove Balcony" room which was pretty neat. These are balcony rooms down on the 2nd deck. Very close to the water. They do have an outer water tight door that I guess they close in high seas, but we never had to close it even though it got pretty rough one night. The only issue we had with our room was the next door neighbors going out on their balcony at 6am each morning and letting the door slam. I guess the 2 folks in that room would each go out once. Person 1 out... BAM, Person 2 out... BAM. Person 1 back in..BAM... Person 2 in ...BAM. We usually had at least 4 slams each morning. This was pretty annoying as the balcony door is right next to where the head of our bed was.

Port and Shore Excursions


The post is not so nice, as it's in an industrial complex. There are some nice reefs for snorkeling. We also discovered the beach at Lucaya National Park. It's beautiful, and not crowded. If you want to go there, rent a moped or car. We did a kayak tour that ended at the beach, so that's a good option as well.
Read 779 Freeport Reviews

Really neat port. We just walked to a nearby park with a fort and beach. Last time there we did a kayak in the mangroves. If you don;t want do do an excursion, just get off and walk around. There lot's to do right by the docks.
Read 738 Key West Reviews

Lot's to do here. The big resort casino on Paradise Island (Atlantis) is pretty nice (not cheap). You can also just walk around town by the docks and see a lot. We have had good luck hiring a taxi for a private tour as well from the dock area.
Read 2645 Nassau Reviews

Thank You For Signing Up!

Please Note: To ensure delivery of your free e-letters, please add news@cruisecritic.com to your address book.
We're committed to protecting your privacy and will not rent or sell your e-mail address. By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.