My wife and I just finished a week long cruise on the beautiful Carnival Magic. Background info: we're both in our mid-30's and traveled from Seattle to celebrate our 10th anniversary. We've cruised several times before, but it's been seven years since the last one. Our two children stayed behind and spent the week with the grandparents.
First, let me just say that we were a bit leery heading into the cruise with some of the reviews posted here. However, we experienced a fantastic voyage. I am beginning to wonder if some people look for things to complain about. The fellow passengers, mostly hailing from Texas, were a friendly bunch. We made a number of new friends that I'm sure we'll maintain contact with.
The Magic herself is gorgeous! The bright colors throughout enhances the experience sailing throughout the Caribbean. We tried virtually every activity that was offered: ropes course, both water slides, spa treatments, fitness center (almost daily), shows, comedy, Vibe dance club, ocean plaza, karaoke, pools, hot tubs, outdoor movies, etc. The comedy was a highlight of the trip! The only minor disappointment was the performer who juggled on the second to last night. Many folks walked out and my wife and I thought that Noonan, the CD, should have used "the hook" to pull him off the stage.
1371 was a quiet, specious cabin and I highly recommend it. The only noise is when the pilot boat comes alongside and the door underneath the cabin is opened. Avoid 1275, we stayed there the first night, but couldn't sleep with an intermittent banging noise.