I chose this cruise because it was newer. I was intrigued by the carousel, Central Park and Broadway and aqua theatre. This was our first time doing my time dining and I don't think I will do it again. You aren't guaranteed the same waiter and that's important to us. We did request our same waiter and we're lucky enough to get him a few times. The entertainment was wonderful. I will say the cruise director and activities director were awesome and worked well together. Our room attendant was very polite and friendly and always had our room cleaned up by the time we came back from breakfast no matter what time we went same with getting our bed ready for night it was always done when we came back from dinner. The room attendant in the next hallway was so friendly always said hello and good evening, enjoy your day, how was your day on the island. Guest services were very quick to help when I misplaced my purse and whenever we had a question.