Overall, this was a very good cruise. The dining service at table 476 and entertainment were exceptional. This was a last minute cruise just to get away for a few days so we were not looking for anything special.
From a constructive criticizm stand point, A of the S is ready for dry dock, which we understand is due in October. The linens were showing wear, seats in the theater were also showing wear. We had an interior cabin with a shower leakage and a closet door that was coming off. While the food was good, the menu needed updating. We understand this is happen in the near future.
We did excursion every other day, one of which we booked through the ship (Buck Island snorkle-great crew) and one we did based on Cruise Critic recommendations (Spencers Tours in St. Lucia). Both were excellent On St. Thomas we did Magic Ice which was a lot of fun. Not quite what we expected, but a lot of fun if you think of Norwegian ice in the Carabbean.
The Pan American pier that RC uses is average