We are experienced cruises over 60 cruises and 35 with Celebrity. So clearly we are Celebrity biased.
Embarkation day was a disaster. Other than a cruise starting in Ensenato it was the worse. We arrived at 1130 am and system changed for check in. We just got off the Silhouette in November and they changed everything so no one knew where to direct Elite Plus people and when we finally got to the right line it took 45 minutes for check in. We are spoiled. Usually takes 5 - 10. So not a good start.
Room was a veranda 6136 and it was like all cabins on a S class ship. We love the rooms and are used to them. No issues all week. Our room steward was just ok. He cleaned our room at a certain time and he did not vary however that was always when we return from breakfast and then the cafe bacio. So everyday when we returned at 11am he was still doing his thing. No big deal, but not great. Little things on the cruise kept this cruise from being outstanding.