Went on the 5 night to Belize and Cozumel. Had a great time! We arrived at 11:40 and were on the ship by noon. Departure was just as easy. We carried our bags off at 8:30 and were in a taxi by 8:45. Liberty personnel were at the elevators telling everyone to just go straight to Deck 1.
Only ate in the Windjammer three times. Once for lunch at arrival and twice for breakfast. Never had a hard time finding a table (for 6) and the waiters were reasonably attentive. It is a buffet after all.
Had the late seating in the MDR and service was fantastic. Was a little nervous about ordering the lamb after reading some reviews but it was cooked perfect and fell of the bone. Prime rib was average. All the soups were very good. Escargot was replaced by small scallops but the dinner portion were large. Night 4 they have a fried seafood platter. Probably their worst dish, at least on our trip. Salmon was still moist, all cooked medium. The duck was another table favorite.
Normal inside cabin. Great closet and cabinet space. Very clean. One night we heard the Catacombs for a few minutes otherwise very quiet. Very little foot traffic.