I had read dozens of reviews of the Carnival Splendor before embarking and having sailed Carnival twice before - both mediocre experiences, I knew what to expect. However, I was cautious nonetheless having read several negative reviews.
And, I am glad to report I was very, very pleasantly surprised. We had a very nice and relaxing cruise. I have sailed on 15 cruises with various lines - some worse, some better - but for middle of the road, the Splendor was fine.
EMBARKATION: A snap. From curbside to having lunch on the lido - 20 minutes top. Everything was all smiles, politeness and efficiency. And we received our bags within two hours of boarding.