Went on the Oasis in 2010 and now on Allure in 2012. Thoroughly enjoyed both cruises but can't say one was better than the other. Here's my take on things.
Arrived at 11:30 and check-in was a breeze. Embarkation was delayed and did not get aboard until 12:30. Last time we got right aboard and the rooms were ready. We bypassed the Windjammer and went straight to the Park Cafe for the yummy Roast Beef sandwiches for lunch. (Last time we didn't find this place until the next day)
Our Balcony room- close to the elevator- centrally located on the 6th deck. The one great improvement was the plug receptacle was on top of the counter instead of under the counter on the Oasis. THANK YOU! And the layout of the room was perfect with the bed near the balcony - giving the room spaciousness.
Layout was great - bed near the balcony - not near the door.
Good size closet with plenty of hangers.
Centrally located on the ship- close to elevators, dining room, promenade, boardwalk, photo shop