This tour was everything promoted. The guide was informative and quite helpful. Unfortunately, we landed in an alternative Port (La Spezia), which is further from Pisa, so time was limited. But the guide did everything in his power to make it a great experience. Be aware that there is a walk from the bus to the Field of Miracles. Every promotional item talks about it, but many seemed quite surprised. They shouldn't be and you shouldn't be either.
Read greg_lindeblom's full Celebrity Silhouette cruise review