We booked "Cozumel by Land and Sea". The semi-submersible boat was the best part of the tour. It was similar to others that we've experienced before with plenty of reef formations and tropical fish.
The stop at the Mayan Cacao Company was simple with a brief history of cacao and chocolate making. You can taste a pure cacao drink and purchase multiple flavors of chocolate bars.
The stop at the Tequileria was interesting, and those on the tour were able to sample many types of tequila.
Unfortunately this tour didn't start until the afternoon, and was four hours long, requiring us to really hustle to get back to the ship before departure. It would be better if it started earlier, or if the tour operator would keep better track of time at each stop.
Read jnc3's full Carnival Magic cruise review
Carnival Cruise Line