Celebrity Silhouette Cruise Review by navybankerteacher
- Sail Date: February 2012
- Destination: Eastern Caribbean
- Cabin Type: Deluxe Veranda
The ship is modern, and fairly well laid out. The lack of a full promenade deck is unfortunate - and is not made up for by the narrow jogging track on an upper deck - which gets dangerously slippery in wet weather. There are numerous attractive bars and lounges, and the theater is very well laid out. The entertainment was about average -- very good production shows balanced by a fairly poor stand-up comic -- offset by an amazingly good ventriloquist. There are a number of speciality restaurants - which deserve their good reviews -- but which make the quality of the food in the main dining room suffer in comparison. The service was good, but the meats were generally tough and tasteless, the fish almost uniformly poorly prepared. The Ocean View cafeteria was well managed, and the quality of the food there seemed batter than in the MDR.
The cabin - "luxury" verandah - was spacious, with an ample verandah area, and the bathroom was very well designed - with above average storage space and a spacious shower with curved sliding doors -- a distinct improvement over the usual small space with a curtain which tends to cling to the bather. The clothes storage was a real problem - one small closet (with no shelves), which was so shallow that clothes had to hang at an angle - using up much of the already insufficient space. Much of the under-bed space was taken up by wire baskets holding life preservers. The very small side tables had no drawers, making them almost useless. Theere was a large storage space above the head of the bed - which was difficult for anyone much shorther than 6 feet tall to use --- and a good portion was dedicated to some duvet filler.The staff were uniformly helpful, competent and cheerful. The attitude of the staff was the strong point. I found the senior personnel, from the captain with his delightful sense of humor, to dining room managers and passenger service staff all above average.
All told, the itinerary, the quality of the staff and the good weather combined to make an enjoyable cruise: good value for the fare -- and which largely overcame some of the unfortunate design elements and the disappointing quality of the MDR food -- since the service and the itinerary were what mattered most to me, I would have to rate the over-all experience as good.
I would like to sail Celebrity again - hopefully they can focus on food quality, while maintaing staff attitude.
Port & Shore Excursion Reviews
AntiguaSome nice beaches, but little else.View All 1,278 Antigua Cruise Port Reviews
View Cruise Critic's Antigua Cruise Port Review
LabadeeA well laid-out and staffed private beach.View All 1,457 Labadee Cruise Port Reviews
View Cruise Critic's Labadee Cruise Port Review
San JuanA wonderful old city to wander around - and a beautiful, late-night sail-away.View All 3,096 San Juan Cruise Port Reviews
View Cruise Critic's San Juan Cruise Port Review
St. CroixNot much to see or do.View All 363 St. Croix Cruise Port Reviews
View Cruise Critic's St. Croix Cruise Port Review
St. MaartenFar and away the most interesting island in the Caribbean. Great beaches, good towns, friendly people.View All 4,134 St. Maarten Cruise Port Reviews
View Cruise Critic's St. Maarten Cruise Port Review
St. ThomasOver-crowded - not much to commend it except as a shopping opportunity.View All 4,106 St. Thomas Cruise Port Reviews
View Cruise Critic's St. Thomas Cruise Port Review