Embarkation was very smooth and well-coordinated. We had absolutely no wait to board the ship and were on by about 11:15. The Life Boat drill was also the most painless we have experienced in 23 cruises - kudos to Carnival for smoothing out that entire process. Disembarkation was another story entirely. For the first time in a long time we did not select the self-assist option which was a huge mistake. We were Zone 22 and did not get off the ship until about 10:30. Last time on Carnival in Galveston we were on the road home by 8:30!

We were disappointed in the Magic. The entire ship seems to be chopped into small boxy areas which were always very crowded. It was impossible to participate in Trivia at the Ocean Plaza because all of the tables were occupied with card and domino players. They obviously had no other location to gather. There seem to be very few public rooms for the passenger capacity of the ship. Poor design throughout leaving no circulation room for the crowds of adults and mobs of children. (Aren't kids supposed to be in school in February?) Even the fitness center was small, dark and almost depressing. Every single public area seemed tiny when taking into account the passenger capacity.

Our stateroom was very nice with plenty of storage. Cabin Attendant, Artawan, did a great job. The room was always very promptly and thoroughly cleaned. Read more