The Carnival Magic...a new ship that was disappointing. : Carnival Magic Cruise Review by twostepmomma

Carnival Magic 4
Member Since 2008
29 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

The Carnival Magic...a new ship that was disappointing.

Sail Date: January 2012
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Galveston
This was my first experience on a large ship. It was also the first time I was told more than once that we had 4500 passengers on board as a reason things were done as they were done. Not an excuse in my estimation.

I am not a person that complains about anything much on cruises, but I was very disappointed in this "new" ships layout and how some things were handled. The look of the ship was excellent. It should look nice and clean because it's new. The staff and service on board were excellent. No complaints about any of that.

My question is "who in world designed this ship and what were they thinking?"
There are two decks where everything is located; Deck 10 and Deck 5.

The main pool areas are located on deck 10. There are 8 hot tubs on this ship and none in the main pool area. Four are located on deck 10 and upper and 4 on deck 5. The ones on deck 5 you have to walk through the casino to get to. Not very what I wanted to do in my More bathing suit.

The theater does not accommodate the number on passengers on board. Not even in two shows. It's very small and uncomfortable. Don't sit in the balcony...the seats sit straight up and your knees touch the seat snugly in front of you. No room to put your legs.

In the lobby area a band plays to the elevators. The singers sang and played everyday to the elevators. There was a huge dance floor but people did not feel it was a very inviting place to hang out because no one ever was there very much. A wasted space. Deck 5 is the other deck where everything else is located. You can walk from the theater to the dining rooms with the rest in between. The problem is around the Atrium area there was never any room to walk because all of the shops had all of their stuff piled up outside. Not a good flow

You could not use the sauna or the steam room unless you paid for it. On most ships this is free.

The Serenity adult area on an upper deck forward was extremely windy and the water from the hot tubs would blow up in your face.

The Red Tree Frog Pub was innovative. The beer was good.

The Waterworks area for kids is awesome on this ship. Also a large basketball court and putt putt gold course. There is also a neat ropes course that all enjoyed.

We loved the Anytime Dining options as well.

Happy Sailing! Less

Published 02/06/12

Cabin review: 4H10289 Interior

Read All Interior (4H) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

Been here 15 times. Take a taxi for $20 to Paradise Beach. Pay $2 a person for a pool, changing rooms, restrooms, beach, and chairs. Food is available for purchase. Very good Guacamole there.
Read 5469 Cozumel Reviews

Great tour for Stingrays..Soto Tour...super! Or take a cab to Calico Jacks on 7 mile beach. Great place and beautiful beach. Clean restrooms and dressing areas. Nice port but I hate tendering.

Jamaica can be scary. We take a cab down to Doctor's Cave Beach...$5. It's $5 to get into the beach. $5 for chairs. There are changing rooms and restrooms. Walk up the street for souvenirs and end up at Margaritaville. Here you can eat, but watch your tab and keep up with what you buy. They will tip themselves big. You can also swim there and go down tubes. Lots of Jamaicans hassle you to let them drive you to the ship. Just ignore them or say you already have a driver. No harm.

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Western Caribbean Cruises

Read more Carnival Magic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Magic Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Western Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2008
29 Forum Posts
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Carnival Magic deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Carnival Magic 70% Loved It

7 Day Exotic Western Caribbean
See all Carnival Magic Deals >>