First time cruise: Liberty of the Seas Cruise Review by jenlaur

Liberty of the Seas 4
Member Since 2012
19 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

First time cruise

Sail Date: January 2012
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Fort Lauderdale (Port Everglades)
My husband and I have been on small boats before that we sailed ourselves. The largest was 47'. So I was not sure what to expect on our first cruise. Some things were great, some, not so much.


Embarkation was long but uneventful - sort of. We live 3 hours north of the port so we drove. We arrived at the baggage drop off and it seemed rushed and rather disorganized. The police barked orders at us to hurry up and my husband scratched the paint on the bumper of the car hurrying to unload our stuff. I went to park the car and he apparently waited quite a long time for someone to come help with the bags. I understand that the Liberty is a very large ship and getting over 3000 people on board has got to be a major feat so we really gave this experience little more thought until now. The scratch on the bumper is an irritating reminder.

The Ship

The ship is beautiful and seems expertly maintained. I enjoyed looking at all of the woodwork and the More decor. Some of the art work is amazing. I saw a few "out of order" but almost everything was in good shape and in working order. I love all of the different bars and intimate areas you could get away to. The promenade was beautiful. We did not shop so I can't comment on the prices. Loved Ben and Jerry's and the pizza place was good.

The Service

Everyone had a smile on. It is amazing to me that these workers can be so friendly and smile at everyone all day long. And after you leave the ship on your last day they welcome 3000+ more people that very afternoon!

Our Room

Our balcony cabin was much nicer and more spacious than I expected. I thoroughly enjoyed the balcony and would get one again. The room was very clean.

The Activities and Shows

We did not do the flo rider or the rock wall (too windy for my husband on the day he was going to try it).
We saw Up in the Air and the ice show, both were amazing and very entertaining. We went to a battle of the sexes show in the bar (it was just OK). The pools were very nice. The energy was high in the pool with the entertainment and the crowd was large. We hung out in the quiet pool with the comfy chairs. Being Floridians we were cold most of the time and did not go in the water (it was cool and very windy the entire trip). The cantilevered spa was very nice.

The Food

This has to be one of the more disappointing parts of the trip. We ate breakfast and lunch at the Windjammer and found the food rather tasteless and uninspiring. There was nothing I would have seconds of with the exception of the salad bar. We had breakfast in the main dining room twice and dinner one night. All meals were below average. One night we dined at Chops with turned out to be one of the highlights of the cruise. The food and service were exceptional. Portofino's was not great. We would not go back there. Service was marginal and the food was overcooked. We ate at Johnny Rockets and the burger and onion rings were very good. All of our drinks were very good. Most of my pina coladas (my drink of the week!) had rum floaters on top. Be warned though....those pina coladas add up! At $7 a drink we were a little shocked at our bill at the end of our trip. We are not big drinkers either. And we kept track of everything so we know the bill was correct. We had room service one morning which was nice. Unfortunately it was the same boring food.

The Spa and Gym

I had one of the best massages ever. However, my appointment was 1/2 hour late and they seemed rather unapologetic. I had to rush to get ready for dinner because of it. It was very windy on our trip and you can really feel the boat rocking when you are in the spa. But I find that relaxing and it just added to the experience. The gym is very nice. They have anything you could want or need in there. We had a $100+ spa service that we never received on our final bill. Not sure how that happened since I pre-paid the spa services. They promptly removed the charge.

The Smoking

Hands down, the worst part of the trip. I absolutely hate smoking and if truly offends me. As soon as we got on the ship we went to our cabin and opened the balcony door. The people in the next room were smoking and the smoke filled our room. We had to shut the door and could go on our balcony only when the ship was underway or the same thing would happen. The casino was unbearable it was so smoky. Even the no smoking section. People were smoking in the bars and around the pools. I find it hard to believe that smoking is even allowed on a ship. What if someone throws their lit cigarette in the garbage and starts a fire? In my opinion it is a disaster waiting to happen.


We really did not get to see the city as we had a dive planned. We did not go through the ship rather we booked with Alison (found out about her on and she was great. We took a taxi to her marina. We dove to about 70' and did a lot of swim throughs. This was the warmest day, about 80. The water temp was 77-79. Visibility was roughly 50 - 60'. Alison dropped us off at the ship after our dives.


It was very long. Seems like it took forever to get through customs. They could definitely improve here. Less

Published 02/03/12

Cabin review: D16386 Superior Oceanview Stateroom with Balcony

We had a cabin with a balcony. It was great! The room was more spacious than I expected and it was very clean and well maintained.

Read All Superior Oceanview Stateroom with Balcony (D1) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

Dropping off bags was very chaotic. The police were yelling at people and there were so many passengers waiting to check bags and not enough workers to help. The police told me to move the car but seemed to not want to take the time to tell me where. I drove off and asked one of the port workers and he told me where to go. I parked the car and my husband said it took a very long time for someone to help with the bags. There was trash everywhere. The area is not very well maintained. Getting through customs upon return took entirely too long. Twice as long as it should of in my opinion.

Compare Prices on Liberty of the Seas Western Caribbean Cruises

Read more Liberty of the Seas cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Liberty of the Seas Review >>

Compare Prices on Liberty of the Seas Western Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2012
19 Forum Posts
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Liberty of the Seas deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Liberty of the Seas 76% Loved It

7 Night Western Caribbean Cruise
See all Liberty of the Seas Deals >>