Carnival Magic Cruise Review by oceansedge
- Sail Date: December 2011
- Destination: Western Caribbean
- Cabin Type: Spa Interior
We don't understand why Carnival is afraid to enforce their dress policy, however. Why publish Cruise Elegant guidelines if you're going to allow a guy in a baseball cap and a guy in shorts to dine in the Northern Lights on Cruise Elegant nights? This is just disrespectful to the other guests.
Also, we did not understand why unaccompanied children were allowed to sit at the bar in the Red Frog Pub, then hop from table to table. The ship provides plenty of kid's spaces, so why are they allowed in the bar without parents? The bartender informed us he did not want to offend them by asking them to leave.
The food in the Prime Steakhouse was excellent, although the portions were overwhelming! Service was fantastic! Can't say the same for the food or the service in the Northern Lights, though. In fact, the last night of our cruise, the food was so bad that no one at our table even ate it!
Overall, we'll stick to the smaller cruise lines from now on. Having said that, we still would not have missed this opportunity to sail on such a beautiful ship!
Port & Shore Excursion Reviews
Belize CityNo excursion planned, but we intended to go and just explore on our own. However, the lines to get on the "relaxed" tenders were so long, that we just gave up and stayed aboard ship.View All 2,217 Belize City Cruise Port Reviews
View Cruise Critic's Belize City Cruise Port Review
Costa MayaWe just enjoyed hanging out and watching the kids swim with the dolphins.View All 1,903 Costa Maya Cruise Port Reviews
View Cruise Critic's Costa Maya Cruise Port Review
CozumelAgain, we just stayed on our own, walking around the town. Had a great lunch at Pancho's, bought souvenirs, listened to Mariachis.View All 5,718 Cozumel Cruise Port Reviews
View Cruise Critic's Cozumel Cruise Port Review
RoatanWe loved our excursion to the private island beach. The beach was gorgeous. We were served a fabulous lunch...Chilean Sea Bass with all the trimmings! It was a wonderful day!View All 2,529 Roatan Cruise Port Reviews
View Cruise Critic's Roatan Cruise Port Review