After much research & not many optioned with in our time constraint of planning a pre-Holiday vacation out of Miami with our three 14-19 children & one 19 yr. old girlfriend, I settled with Carnival's Liberty.
I have to admit in spite of hours of research, & reading the boards & posting my own questions I immediately had buyers remorse.
Where I anticipated concern & disappointment was exactly where I found it. These boards are true to form!