(Took my son and his wife and kids on this cruise for his 40th Birthday.
If we hadn't brought decorations and paid $50 for a cake, he'd never have had a "happy b-day wish" from RCCL (although we ordered the birthday package it never came!)
Our travel agent sent chocolate covered strawberries to the 'adults' and cupcakes to the kids, and a bottle of Champagne to our table at dinner. The staff made no attempt.)
8232 was fine. That's it...just fine!