First time on Holland America: Nieuw Amsterdam Cruise Review by DonAndBetty

Nieuw Amsterdam 4
Member Since 2011

Overall Member Rating

First time on Holland America

Sail Date: November 2011
Destination: Eastern Caribbean
Embarkation: Fort Lauderdale (Port Everglades)
We were excited about taking our first cruise on Holland America Line because we had heard so many good things. Sadly we were a little underwhelmed. Our cruise was on the Nieuw Amsterdam. It was a nice clean ship and the staff was great, but we were expecting something a little more elegant and more enriching activities. We were also disappointed in the ride of the ship. Even though we were on calm seas the ship rocked from side-to-side continually throughout the cruise. Since the Nieuw Amsterdam was a newer ship we thought the ride would have been significantly smoother considering the seas. The Nieuw Amsterdam was nicer than the Carnival ships we had been on, but not as nice as the Royal Caribbean ships. The ship was sold-out, but it never felt crowded and we never had to wait in line more than a few minutes. Our verandah stateroom was nicely appointed and the bed was very comfortable. There was ample closet space and the adjustable shower head was a nice More touch.

The food in the dining room was very well done and had a nice selection every night. The first night the temperature of the food was a little cold, but the rest of the cruise they seemed to have worked out the timing kinks.

The Tamarind was excellent and the staff was great. The Tamarind is a must when you have the chance and definitely worth the $15. Be sure to make reservations though.The Culinary Arts Center was one of the main reasons we wanted to take a cruise on Holland America. From we were anticipating actual cooking demonstrations and classes in the CAC. This did not happen. We only attended a couple of events in the CAC. After the first 2 were so lame we didn't go back. One of the events seemed to have a little promise in the beginning, but failed in the end. The event was to have a chef from each of the specialty restaurants demonstrate a dish from their menu. Each chef brought everything pre-prepared and put the dishes together in the showroom while poking fun at each other's restaurants. They explained very little about their dish or what they were doing. The other event we went to was supposed to be an appetizer demonstration by the ship's "Party Planner". She too had everything pre-prepared and went through the process of using Oriental soup spoons to display shrimp cocktail. If you have watch the Food Channel more than a few times you will probably be disappointed in the CAC. Don't choose Holland America because of the CAC.

The spa area was very nice, but you are constantly bombarded with product sales pitches which made it really hard to relax and enjoy the environment.

We did attend several of the dance classes and had fun. The dancers from the show staff were the instructors and they did a great job. They made everyone feel comfortable and took the time to help people individually. The only complaint would be that the space in the Northern Lights area was a little small for the number of people that attended each class.

One thing that was enjoyable about the ship was the absence of blaring caribbean music in the pool areas and Lido restaurant like some of the other cruise lines use. The music throughout the ship was kept at a nice enjoyable volume even when there were deck activities. Less

Published 12/12/11

Cabin review: SA7095 Neptune Suite with Verandah

Nice verandah, comfortable bed, big closet, very quiet even though it is close to elevator.

Read All Neptune Suite with Verandah (SA) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

The port area of Grand Turk is very nice, but the rest of the island leaves a lot to be desired. We took a $10 cab ride to downtown, which was a joke. In 15 minutes we were ready to go back to the port which cost another $10. Needless to say we will not be taking any cruises that have Grand Turk on the itinerary.
Read 1707 Grand Turk Reviews

In San Juan we took the Bacardi/Fort tour. It was a good value and very interesting. Pedro was our tour guide and he did an excellent job.
Read 2982 San Juan Reviews

Compare Prices on Nieuw Amsterdam Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Read more Nieuw Amsterdam cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Nieuw Amsterdam Review >>

Compare Prices on Nieuw Amsterdam Eastern Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2011
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Skip X

See Nieuw Amsterdam deals up to 82% off:

October Deals
Nieuw Amsterdam 74% Loved It

16-day Panama Canal
See all Nieuw Amsterdam Deals >>