Didn't Know What to Expect: Carnival Magic Cruise Review by HopewellKat

Carnival Magic 3
Member Since 2011

Overall Member Rating

Didn't Know What to Expect

Sail Date: November 2011
Destination: Western Caribbean
Embarkation: Galveston
My father booked this cruise for my two sisters and me to join him over Thanksgiving. We were without our families so the trip was just us for the first time in many years. That aspect of it was really great. My father and one sister had been on several cruises, but one sister and I were newbies.

First, the ship itself is amazing. Maybe too big for it's own good, but I was impressed. Our balcony cabin was more than adequate. Two twin beds, a sofa, and a bathroom (with a shower) that was fine. My sister LOVED the shower. Our steward, Augustina, took very good care of us and my father certainly put him through his paces. Our rooms (not connected, disappointingly) are at the front of the ship and that was a lot of fun. I was told by many that I would hardly know I was on a ship, but that was not true. Sailing was rocky several days and VERY rocky two nights.

I found most of the entertainment to be fun though the "comic juggler" was more than disappointing. I More most enjoyed the Close Up Magic. While the illusions in the Destination Unknown show are unimpressive, the show itself is spectacular - visually entertaining. Another show with a guy named Marcus something or other was slow and boring. The comedians seemed to rely to heavily on stereotypes, but there were some good laughs.

The service was mostly quite good. In the Southern Lights upper dining room, we all felt the hostess, Elizabeth, was particularly attentive and like the maitre d, Igor. Our food was mostly average or below average though the lobster stands out as particularly good as were many of the appetizers. I found the soups to be quite good and tried as many as I could. My dad and sister who had been on several cruises felt the food was below average and were disappointed. Some of the options were simply to difficult to try due to long lines and limiting hours of operation. I never got a chance to have sushi at the sushi bar. The Red Frog pub is nice, but our server was not efficient though we had heard they were fantastic there. I didn't mind paying $3.33 for the pub snacks.

Now: The Lido Deck. It's all happening here judging by the crowds. We enjoyed people watching and some of the activities, but it IS CROWDED. The pools were very cold and the hot tubs were just barely warm. Some were closed for a day at a time. The Lido Marketplace is severely over-crowded with little to no service assistance. I wanted to try things and enjoy it, I just didn't - the lines were far too long and service poor to awful.

The cruise director, James, was only interested in making announcements and selling things. I resent that. I already bought a cruise and I spent plenty of money on the ship - stop "milking" me already!

The Serenity Deck is very nice and it was great to be in an adults-only area.

My worst experience was in the spa. I had booked two spa treatments online. The first, a pedicure, was nice, but not worth the money. The second was a true "splurge" for me as I am on a tight budget (school teacher with two kids in college). I booked a 75 minute massage. The therapist came to get me late and began late. She stopped 55 minutes later after spending only about 35 minutes on the massage and 20 arranging hot stones. I questioned the timing and she argued. When I reminded her she started late, she agreed and tried to massage my head for 10 more minutes. It was awful. I left very upset. The did give me a 25 minute massage the next day and it was fine, but definitely not what I had booked and paid for. The receptionist was exceptionally kind and helpful. I wish I knew her name so I could thank her.

The ports were fun. We did not book excursions but rather figured out things to do/see on our own and from what I heard probably made a good decision there.

Overall, the cruise was enjoyable, but Carnival did NOT live up to all the wonderful things I've heard. I will probably book my next cruise on a different line. At Nassau, a Disney ship docked next to us and looked like a fun ship. Less

Published 12/12/11

Cabin review: 8E6212 Balcony

Cabin 6212: Nicely sized; small, but pleasant balcony; nicely located at front of ship; excellent shower; plenty of storage for my sister and me.

Read All Balcony (8E) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

We found a driver to take us to a beach club. The club itself is somewhat run-down, but the driver was wonderful to us and we had a good time. I like the "real" feel of it. I've never been big on glossy resorts. The beach was clean and lots of fun.
Read 1206 Freeport Reviews

We walked around,went to Hemingway's house, and had mojitos. All in all, it was enjoyable. The weather was outstanding.
Read 1393 Key West Reviews

Nassau is extremely crowded and with five ships ported that day, more so. We had intended to walk around but when we saw that would be nearly impossible with my father in a motorized chair, we hired a van (they quickly found us one that would accommodate him) and went on a tour. The driver was lovely and friendly. We got to see a lot of sights we would have missed on a pre-purchased excursion. The area around the port was almost impossible to get around, though.
Read 5046 Nassau Reviews

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Western Caribbean Cruises

Read more Carnival Magic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Magic Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Western Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2011
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Skip X

See Carnival Magic deals up to 82% off:

October Deals
Carnival Magic 70% Loved It

7 Day Exotic Western Caribbean
See all Carnival Magic Deals >>