Hi. Joined Cruise Critic a few months ago, so I'm a first time reviewer here. :)
I don't have a ton of cruising experience so I don't have too much to compare it to. But for the most part, I was happy with the cruise.
There were 11 of us in our group, from Grandparents (age 70), my sibling (44) and her family (45, 20, 14, 12, 10), a friend (20) and my fiancee (32). Everyone was pleased with the Carnival Dream, though there were a few things we think could be tweaked.
8343, was what I expected. The balcony was nice. I liked the little cosmetic freebees they had in the bathroom (razor, breathe right, body wash, etc). The beds were comfy, though I found the pillows hard. Our room steward was very efficient but quiet. He didn't introduce himself ever, but he did his job well. Prior to our trip I read some reviews that said their staterooms were noisy. We didn't experience that, though sometimes I heard the elevators chiming. We didn't hear much, though from time to time we heard chairs scraping the floor from above. We never heard anyone in the hot tub or walkways down on the 5th floor. Mid 8 was a great location!