• TRAVEL NOTICE: Learn more about COVID-19
  • Newsletter
  • Write a Review
  • Boards
  • Find a Cruise
  • Reviews
  • Cruise Tips
  • News
  • Deals

Carnival Magic Review

4.0 / 5.0
Editor Rating
1404 reviews
3 Awards

Wrong kind of Wow factor.

Review for Carnival Magic to Transatlantic
User Avatar
10+ Cruises • Age 60s

Rating by category

Public Rooms
Fitness & Recreation

Additional details

Sail Date: Oct 2011
Cabin: Interior

I have always been a Carnival fan. Even my wedding was on Carnival, but this newest ship is headed the wrong direction. The 16 day transatlantic was the final leg of cruising completely around the world. When we arrived on board it was surprising how much damage there was for such a new ship. The lightweight aluminum cones in the elevators and halls were bent and damaged from the countless scooters and wheelchairs on board. What were they thinking when they put the Serenity area right next to the Water Works. I found nothing serene about hearing the screams all the way down the two slides.

I used to say that Carnival's food was better than Princess, but not on this voyage. Pasta and fish was undercooked, variety missing, but worst of all our waiter was so overworked that he didn't ever have the opportunity to check back to see if the food was OK. Once it was served, we didn't see him again until he brought dessert because he was so overwhelmed. Even the Maitre-d made an announcement to everyone one night apologizing for the food and service.

The single biggest problem, I could identify is that it is too many people for the size of the ship or they have not yet figured out how to manage 4,000 pax like RCCL. There were always mobs waiting to get in for the shows. If you were not in a seat 45 minutes before a show, you were out of luck. The cruise director tried to compensate by not even promoting the final shows in hopes that enough would not see it in the "Fun Times" publication. Every day the "Top Ten" recommended things to do had at least five that required spending more money. I felt like I had paid for a 16 day commercial always being asked to spend more, spend more, spend more. Every time we ordered a drink and specifically asked for "House" liquor, they upgraded and charged extra. After confronting them, they would no longer come by and ask us if we wanted a drink. The other overall problem was noise pollution throughout the ship. Speakers were too loud, acoustics in the dining were so bad we could never hear the conversation at our 10 top. On a more positive note, I did find the cabin roomy and I'm glad they have returned to having dancing in the Atrium. Thanks also for placing the second area for entertainment not "in" the promenade walkway, but rather beside it. Overall, I would say that the Carnival Magic has cured me from wanting to go on Carnival again.

Cabin Review


Cabin was spacious, but closet pole goes front to back??? Enjoyed having frig and hairdryer provided. Found requirement to put cabin key in slot for lights annoying.

previous reviewnext review

Find a Carnival Magic Cruise from $204

Want to cruise smarter?
Get expert advice, insider tips and more.
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy and Cookies Statement and Terms of Use.