MSC Magnifica was a great ship and a fun cruise.: MSC Magnifica Cruise Review by tronky

MSC Magnifica 5
Member Since 2011

Overall Member Rating

MSC Magnifica was a great ship and a fun cruise.

Sail Date: October 2011
Destination: Europe - Eastern Mediterranean
Embarkation: Venice
Prior to booking our cruise on MSC Magnifica we read the reviews here on Cruise Critic and to be honest, we were very concerned whether this cruise was going to be a good one or not based on the many negative comments left about this ship. I was convinced before we ever left home that this was going to be a miserable cruise. We had been on two Carnival Cruises prior to this one and both of them were very enjoyable. Neither was perfect and we had our little complaints about this or that on both of those cruises but overall the experience with Carnival was very good and if you read the reviews about Carnival Cruises, generally those reviews reflect that most everyone does enjoy cruising with Carnival. So after reading the mostly bad reviews for the MSC Magnifica we were sure that we were going to be greatly disappointed. Getting from the airport to the cruise port was much easier than anticipated. Plaza Roma where you are transported to is a madhouse, but it's a manageable More madhouse if you plan ahead and my wife had prepared for this trip very well, so she knew what to do and where to go to do it. She had bought us the necessary boat pass to get us to our hotel on Lido Island because we had arrived a day early. She knew how to get us to the People Mover which got us to the free MSC shuttle bus. Going through their boarding process was no different than any we had experienced on Carnival which is to say, not too bad and the wait wasn't too long. Upon arrival on the ship, a steward took us straight to our room. On our Carnival Cruises we were left to find our own rooms and sometimes that can be a bit confusing as you wind yourself around the maze of rooms. Not to worry on MSC, they take you straight to your room.
The ship was clean and it was kept clean the whole cruise. The crew were even painting the ship in every port, keeping it nice and white. The ship was quite compared to our Carnival Cruises. The Lido Deck on Carnival is always crowded and noisy. MSC Magnifica's Lido Deck was quite in comparison. We found many private places to sit and read or to get away from any of the crowded areas. The food on MSC was no better or worse than our two previous Carnival Cruises. We thought the MSC food was very good, prepared fresh and their selections of different types of food was okay. Some of the food they present isn't exactly American-style food but hey, you're on a European Cruise and you should expect changes in the types of food served. Why do we Americans always think that everyone should cater to our specific needs? We are not the only people who live in this world and it's easy to see why some other countries refer to us as "Ugly Americans" because we seem to want what we want and we want it now. A cruise should be a time of relaxation and a time to learn new things and to leave the anxiety behind and just enjoy life as it comes our way.

I agree with other reviews that MSC seems to nickle-and-dime you for everything. Americans and folks from Canada get free water vouchers for dinner, your choice of flat or fizzy water. It's a huge bottle so you have plenty. No they don't serve coffee after dinner but for us we didn't really care too much about that. Other countries have to pay for their water at dinner. At lunch you can eat on their version of the Lido Deck Buffet and get free coffee, tea and water. Yes, they serve the tea and coffee in blue plastic mugs. So what? It doesn't affect the taste of the coffee or tea and the plastic mugs kept the drink hot longer than glass cups. Less breakage for the cruise line too. Not an issue for us.

The food was varied and tasted good. And at dinner we sat at a table with 3 other couples and we all had a great time talking and enjoying our wonderful dinners. Each night the food selection was nice and was based on some area of Italy so they were giving you a taste of food from various parts of Italy. The shows each night in the main theatre were entertaining and good. MSC doesn't badger you about taking photos at every stop, at every occasion like Carnival does. Each port-of-call was fantastic. All the stops we made were different, exciting, fun and enjoyable. We didn't take any of the ship's offered excursions. We just went our own way and did what we wanted to and that worked out just fine in each port. My wife had planned ahead for each port and what we were going to do and that worked out great without having to spend the extra money on MSC provided excursions. Getting tickets for public transportation in each port was easy and almost painless. Use of the different types of money in each port wasn't too difficult. Our shipboard experience was great. We enjoyed the cruise immensely and would definitely use MSC again.

The ship was full of people from everywhere. Australia, Germany, Denmark, Japan, Hong Kong, Italy, Spain and who knows where else. Just listening to all of the different languages might tick some folks off because they weren't speaking English, but most of the time when you spoke to these other people, they would speak English back, so at least they know more than one language, unlike most of us one-language Americans. Everyone always spoke or nodded. All of our contact with the crew was positive and they all spoke English as did almost everyone we talked to in any of the ports. I'm sorry if alot of Americans don't like MSC Magnifica, but we have very little to complain about and we loved our cruise. We enjoyed every minute of it. Less

Published 10/27/11

Cabin review: 2

We had an inside cabin near the middle of the ship on the 10th deck. Very quite, hardly any ship movement. The room had a queen bed that was comfortable. The room itself was typical of an inside cabin with just enough room to do what you need to do. The bathroom was also typical of an inside cabin bathroom with a nice shower, sink, large mirror and toilet. Closet space was sufficient for our needs. The room was clean, well-maintained and fit our needs perfectly.

Port and Shore Excursions

We liked Bari and enjoyed walking around in the all of the small back alleys and just seeing how the people live. We especially liked walking along the sea wall. No one bothered us or tried to sell us something. No hard selling here at all. It's a lovely city with lots of things to see and do.
Read 141 Bari Reviews

This port is excellent. It's clean, easy to get around and the old city where we visited was ancient. MSC provides shuttle service to the old city at a modest cost because the old city is about 20 minutes by bus. You can walk but it's about an hour walk from the ship. They have many shops, cafes, and other things of interest inside the walls of the old city. For a small fee you can climb up and walk around the entire outside wall of the city. This takes about an hour because of the many photo opportunities. There are boat trips you can take around the port, a cable car if you choice to go the top of the mountain. The port itself has a lovely suspension bridge near where the ship docks. There are other shops all along the city leading up to and away from the old city that you an visit if you choose. Again, no one here tries to hard-sell you anything. You just walk along and shop as you please with no hassle from the local folks. This was a lovely port and we enjoyed our visit here.

It's huge! There is no one you can see or appreciate all this city has to offer in the short time the cruise ship is there. Istanbul is a city that needs at least a week to see everything. It's crowded, it's busy, people are everywhere. We took public transportation, the tram, which was clean, fast, and timely. We also did alot of walking, first along the seafront, then to the bridge that will carry you toward the Blue Mosque. We caught the Tram at the bridge and it carried us to the area of the Blue Mosque. There are many attractions in this area, such as museums, the Palace and of course the Blue Mosque. Entrance to the museums and the Palace wasn't free but the price wasn't expensive, but the line to the Palace was very, very long. You can visit the Blue Mosque for free but depending on the time of the day it can be a pretty long line also. Getting around in Istanbul is easy. Their Tram system is extensive and you an reach almost any destination by using the Tram. If not, then they have tons of buses and taxis. We didn't feel in any danger as we walked along the busy streets and no one bothered us at all. We skipped the Bazaar in Istanbul which many people had recommended to visit, but since we had already visited the Bazaar in Izmir, we didn't feel the need to visit this one. Besides we were tired at this point from visiting so many other places in Istanbul that we just passed up the chance to see their Bazaar. We loved Istanbul and it should be on every one's place-to-visit in the future.
Read 403 Istanbul Reviews

This port was wonderful. We walked along the sea front where they have many beautiful parks. There were many fishermen along the sea wall and the breeze from the ocean was fresh and clear. We walked to the center of town and walked along the streets and absolutely no one bothered us or tried to sell us anything. We felt safe and didn't worry too much about having our pockets picked or assaulted. After reading some reviews about Turkey we were a little concerned about it. But no problems at all. We visited their bazaar and did some shopping there. Again, no hard-sells. You walked through the bazaar which was very clean and shopped at your leisure with no one bothering you. We really liked this port.
Read 184 Izmir Reviews

A small Greek port with not so many places to visit except the small downtown portion which isn't very large. But there are alot of stores to shop in and view different products and no one here tries to hard-sell you on anything. There were street vendors but they didn't bother you. The streets were clean and so were the shops. We took a local shuttle for a 30 minute trip around the countryside which gave us a look at local houses, people and scenery. There were orange and olive trees everywhere. Nice place.

Compare Prices on MSC Magnifica Europe - Eastern Mediterranean Cruises

Read more MSC Magnifica cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s MSC Magnifica Review >>

Compare Prices on MSC Magnifica Europe - Eastern Mediterranean Cruises

Member Since 2011
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See MSC Magnifica deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
MSC Magnifica 53% Loved It

2 Night Mediterranean Cruise
See all MSC Magnifica Deals >>