• Cheers to 25 years: Celebrate with Us!
  • Write a Review
  • Boards
  • Log In
  • Find a Cruise
  • Deals
  • Excursions
  • More

Carnival Miracle Review

4.0 / 5.0
Editor Rating
1315 reviews
5 Awards

9/11/2011 Sailing out of NYC

Review for Carnival Miracle to Bermuda
User Avatar
10+ Cruises • Age 40s

Rating by category

Public Rooms

Additional details

Sail Date: Sep 2011
Cabin: Interior with French Door (obstructed views)

When it was time for Sail-Away, we all ended up by the smoke stack. The lights came on, and we watched as they lit up the sky as dusk turned into darkness. A bagpiper walked the decks as he played patriotic songs, and other melodies. It was a beautiful and moving moment, as Captain Alcaras stopped our ship in front of the Freedom Towers. Their red, white, and blue made the depature out of NYC more memorable. As I stood there, with the other Cruise Critic Members, and said silent prayers for those who perished, as well as the families who were left behind, I realized that I was lucky to be such a huge part of a rememberance of 9/11.I don't have any complaints about our cruise. The entertainment was great. I do give the person who was the juggler credit, as he had a few near misses, and played it off very well. That was at the later show. The other memorable entertainment was our Cruise Director, Malcom in the Middle's Silent Films Cast. He chose audience members to participate. The two shows we saw were very exciting. They were also very funny. I give them a lot of credit for having the guts to stand up in front of strangers, and making us all laugh.The Meet and Greet went well. The Cruise Critic Members all enjoyed themselves. The bar staff in Frankie and Johnnie's Jazz Lounge were wonderful, and served us with drinks throughout the one hour open bar. I must admit, they were also one of the reasons why I love Carnival. They really make the atmosphere a positive one. It's so nice to see their friendly and smiling faces, when they're so far away from their home, and family and friends. I never got tired of hearing them say, "Good Morning." I usually am the cherry one in the morning, even without coffee. It was nice to see so many happy people, who were working on the ship.The other events that the Cruise Critic Members had scheduled were a Cabin Crawl, where everyone went from one category to another, an independent trip to the Blue Hole Caves, and last but not least, a Slot Pull, where everyone loads their money into a slot machine, and they each get five pulls, at around $15 per person. We did miss meeting the NCL Gem Cruise Critic Members, as they got rerouted to Florida and the Bahamas. I missed having their ship in the dockyard with us.We were in the lovely Maria's path, and had a lot of gail forced winds, with a lot of water splashing up onto the pier. I didn't want to stay on the ship, or in the room for that matter. So, I wandered through the dockyard, and ran into some fellow Cruise Critic Members, who had the same idea. The staff and crew did their best to make sure that we were all safe getting on and off the ship. They all told us to be careful, and watch our steps, as they were genuinely concerned for our safety. A few of us ended up getting splashed with water from the ocean, as it came up on the pier. Another couple were standing by the edge of the water, on the pier, and ended up almost getting blown into the water. I'm so glad that wasn't George and me.The food was tasty. We never complained once about the quality of the food. We had Your Time Dining, and were always seated promptly. A couple of times we were handed pagers, but it didn't bother us one bit. We were glad to have the extra time to wander outside, and wait for them to beep us when our table was ready. The waiters and waitresses were wonderful as well. I was so glad that the Matire 'D was there to say hello to us. He didn't just pop up on the last night of the ship, with his hand out for the money. We were very pleased that he took the time to go out of his way to say "Hello".Captain Alcaras is a wonderful person. The Cruise Critic Members and I presented him with a plaque and a coin. The plaque had a picture of NYC's skyline, with the two lights that light up the sky. It reads "10 Years Later We Will Always Remember, 9/11 We Will Never Forget". The coin has the State of New York on it. They put it in the display case, where the stores are. It's all the way at the end, near the stairs and the water fall, heading towards the front of the ship. The stores are at Midship.I am very pleased that Captain Alcaras, the NYC mayor's office, The Port Authority, and the Carnival Administrators, all went out of their way to make our delayed sailing a reality. I'm especially thankful for the one and only, Cruise Director, John Heald, for keeping us posted as the details progressed. If it weren't for the wonderful staff who worked tirelessly to pull this off, the delayed sailing wouldn't have been successful.Also, thank you to all of the Cruise Critic Members in being instrumental in planning and setting up all of our activities. It's been a wonderful cruise. I am very glad that I was able to share some fond memories with my fellow Cruise Critic Members. If it weren't for all of you, we wouldn't have had the successful cruise that we all enjoyed and participated in together.

Cabin Review

Interior with French Door (obstructed views)

Cabin 4K

Our cabin was the Inside Cabin with the French Doors on Deck # 4. We couldn't see anything outside, due to the lifeboats in our way, however, we did have the sunlight streaming in when it was morning. The cabin steward was wonderful, as well as his assistants. We couldn't ask for a better experience. The room was plenty big enough, and we had ample closet space, as well as ample room in the bathroom. The shower stall is tiny, with a shower curtain that followed me wherever I went in the tiny shower. I'm not complaining though. I am glad that we had that room category.

Port Reviews

New York (Manhattan)

The embarkation went very smoothly. We got to talk to some of our friends who were on the Cruise Critic Message Board. They were very friendly, and it was great to meet them. I was very pleased with the ease of the embarkation process. Unlike our first time, in 2005, we had to wait in 5 different lines just to embark. Now that they have it down to a science, many of us find the ease of embarking one less hassle to deal with.

After we embarked, we went up to the Lido Deck for lunch. There, we ran into some more Cruise Critic Members who were on our board. It was great to see their smiling faces, and I know that we did encounter some wonderful people right from the beginning.

King's Wharf

We really enjoyed going to Horseshoe Bay Beach, as well as Hamilton. The transportation system was better than we had anticipated. We thought that we'd have some delays in both the buses and the ferries. We were very pleased that we were wrong in our assumptions.

The Bermudaian people are wonderful! They're so friendly, and love to talk to us tourists. The island is so clean, and the water and the beaches are so pristine. We couldn't ask for a better place to visit.

The bathrooms on Horseshoe Bay Beach are public, and we met some people from HAL's MS Veendam, who were docked in St. George's and Hamilton. Those cruisers were very friendly as well. They really keep the bathrooms clean, as well as the areas outside, where we washed off our feet, that had so much sand on them. I am very glad that Captain Alcaras didn't change our course, and that we were able to stay in Bermuda.

Find a Carnival Miracle Cruise from $199

Want to cruise smarter?
Get expert advice, insider tips and more.
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

We have updated the Cruise Critic Privacy and Cookie Statement effective on October 1, 2020. Please click here for more information.