Magic lacking wow factor: Carnival Magic Cruise Review by Cathie Blackwell

Carnival Magic 4
Cathie Blackwell

Overall Member Rating

Magic lacking wow factor

Sail Date: July 2011
Destination: Europe - Western Mediterranean
Embarkation: Barcelona
Booking- easy.I liked being able to pre-book tours and Spa sessions in advance, on the internet.

Boarding in Barcelona- great! Handed cases over to staff who placed them on a conveyor (after checking tag had cabin number on) and entered large, cool terminal building. Up an escalator to a hotel style reception desk to register credit card and collect 'sign + sail key card'. Then they take a photograph so when the card is swiped for any payments on board, your picture comes up on the screen. Entered ship on deck 3- the Atrium. Not quite as spacious as advertised, OK its 7 or 8 floors high but only near the lifts. Disappointing decor, green motif on lights strange and altogether neither cutting edge modern nor classic ship decor.

Amazing organisation with 4,500 passengers to embark- also true in ports we visited!

Cabin on deck 2 easy to find but corridor running full length of ship dauntingly long- could barely see the end of it in the distance. Cabin was More adequate- lots of storage/wardrobe space and comfy bed and pillows. Very strange 70's style pictures of leaves on the walls. Shower was good, lots of bathroom shelving for toiletries. Shower gel and shampoo dispensers. Strange complimentary toiletries- 2 razors and whitening toothpaste but no shower cap, moisturiser or cotton wool pads.

1,400 children on board but didnt seem that many apart from around pools at times.

Food- quite good selection for breakfast & lunch & interesting options including Burrito bar, Tandoori, deli (sandwiches), pasta bar, etc. But nothing much at tea time- from 3pm to 5.30pm you could buy cake & starbucks but buffets were closed. Dinner at the Steakhouse was wonderful but cost additional $30 each.

Entertainment- disappointing overall. Only one typical singing & dancing show. Nothing at all for first 3 nights. Several 'single artist' shows- a soprano, a male singer, an instrumentalist. Last night was a passenger show, a bit like X-factor auditions. Spotlight lounge had magic act and comedians which were Ok.

Big screen movies in Ocean Plaza were great with free popcorn BUT timings meant it was difficult to get to if you dined at 8.15pm

Red Frog pub had good live singer and great ambiance inside and out. Also loved the piano bar and excellent Martinis each night BUT with 15% service charge on all drinks any cocktail cost $10.

Service was generally reasonable, good in the restaurant, exceptional in the Steakhouse. There is an automatic $10 per person per day service charge which I disliked- prefer to tip individuals for good service. Better still, include tips in total cost!

2 pools were good, main one could have been bigger. Often spoilt on 'sea' days by children splashing and jumping in/ Perrenial problem of people putting towels out on best located sunbeds then dissappearing for hours- sometimes for a whole excursion ashore! There were in fact plenty of beds if you walked around a little and didnt mind not being close to a pool.

We loved the Sports area with the mini golf and connect 4 and its own little bar.

Serenity was a lovely 'adult only' area near the Spa with hammocks and double sunbeds but again, many beds often reserved and unoccupied for hours. Lacked a pool though it did have a hot-tub.

Spa was great, cool and tranquil area, great teatments. (I had 3)

Disembarcation. Our flight wasnt until 21.30. but latest disembarcation was 0900. Announcements started at 05.30 so any hope of sleep was spoiled. Also they neglected to inform people about cheap bus into Barcelona and luggage storage facility (near top of Rambla, €7.50 for XL locker which held 2 cases and 1 carry on bag) Less

Published 08/08/11

Cabin review: 4A Interior

Read All Interior (4A) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

This was a magical and unspoilt place. We wandered though the city and walked the walls. The views were exceptional, no wonder Unesco helped restore the place after the war. Have to pay in local currency NOT euros, but ATMs are easy to find near entrance to the walls. We had a great meal overlooking the harbour. Somewhere we would definately consider revisiting.

Delightful! One of my highlights was eating breakfast on board with a view of Monte Carlo. We didnt take a tour but did pay €17 for a hop-on hop-off bus which took us on a tour and we got off at the Casino. Had ice cream and browsed the designer stores. Then back on to the bus and up to the palace. You could spend a couple of hours there before getting the same bus back to the cruise port. Lovely day!

Actually did the Mount Etna trip. Very interesting but not for anyone with walking difficulties of fear of heights!

Venice is beautiful and rates 5+ BUT from where we were docked it was a long walk to the shuttle and that stopped running around 9pm. Vaporetto passes can be purchased near the port but are cheaper if you wait until you get to P d'Roma. There is an electric train shuttle. We took the vaporetto to San Marco and wandered the shopping areas. Then took a vaporetto to Lido where far fewer tourists go and had a delightful cocktail sitting in a pleasant garden with a view of Venice. Then we headed back into Venice and enjoyed the music in San Marco. Beware stopping for a drink here - always expensive, at night they add $6 per person to the bill for music! As we were in port overnight we caught a late vaporetto to P d'Roma which was packed and slow then we had to walk from Plaza d'Roma (at midnight) back to the ship. Lovely day but ended exhausted.

Read 1126 Venice Reviews

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Europe - Western Mediterranean Cruises

Read more Carnival Magic cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Magic Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Magic Europe - Western Mediterranean Cruises

Cathie Blackwell
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Carnival Magic deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Carnival Magic 70% Loved It

7 Day Exotic Western Caribbean
See all Carnival Magic Deals >>