Slight disappointment in our July 2011 cruise: Carnival Glory Cruise Review by ysharpbrown

Carnival Glory 3
Member Since 2011

Overall Member Rating

Slight disappointment in our July 2011 cruise

Sail Date: July 2011
Destination: Canada & New England
Embarkation: New York (Manhattan)
We had 14 people including 5 children with us in total and the choice to go with Carnival was both budget and schedule based - we only booked 2 months in advance. We've been on cruises before as a family (sometimes with upwards of 30 people), but this was by far one of my worst experiences. Call me picky, but this was a list of things I loved, and wish were different:


General service from the front line staff - amazingly friendly wait staff and stewards who wanted to go out of their way to help.

Food - great food variety, though lines were sometimes atrocious on the buffets

Rooms - spacious, clean, in working order, excellent service and turndown service

Family friendly - Club Carnival is generally great for various age groups. We had to separate our 5 children into 3 groups, but the activities were age appropriate.

Games - family friendly games are always great. I only wish BINGO was longer than an hour and cheaper (USD20 More for a 3 cards is a lot, especially when you like playing with multiple cards)

Gym - the gym is spacious and has several machines. Their fitness schedule is also varied. Though I wouldn't suggest paying for their yoga or Pilates - it isn't yoga or Pilates and covers much of the same stuff their free stretching programs include.


Pools - have they shrunk? Seeing a load of adults or children squeezed into tiny pools is anything but refreshing.

Service charges - I'd prefer if mandatory service fees were included in the cost of the cruise. Bump up the prices but make it inclusive and allow guests to tip extra if they'd like. Our family tipped generously in the end to those we liked, but the idea of adding mandatory servie charges onto a bill just seems wrong, especially when cruises are known for their "almost all inclusive" packages.

Charges for soda? - First off, for a cruise that generates as much waste as it does, I'm surprised they use cans and not fountain soda. 2nd of all, I'm not a soda drinker, but shouldn't soda be included in the cost of your cruise? Especially when a cruise is happy to give you unlimited servings of everything else?

Horrific service from supervisors at the Guest Service Desk - While front line staff, entertainment hosts and guest service agents are generous and friendly, the guest service supervisors were astonishingly defensive and rude! It almost seems that any slight complaint or query generates a series of comebacks that state it's the customer's fault and not theirs. Imagine that. In a world of vacations and hospitality, I encountered 2 separate supervisors who were quick to say that it was my fault their landside computer system doesn't necessarily sync to their boatside terminals - which resulted in several billing errors. I won't go into details, but the service from supervisors was so bad it was to be laughed at.

Tours canceled - several tours were canceled due to lack of interest. This meant that we had to chance it by finding tour operators on land ourselves to do what we wanted. Having said that, we had an AMAZING time deep sea fishing with the guys at Murphy's in Halifax. They're located down the boardwalk and will take you out at various times throughout the day.

An idea - some large groups brought walkie talkies with them. I'm not sure how the range is, but it's a great idea if you want to locate people quickly.

In the end, we had a great time because we just plopped ourselves down and played board games. Less

Published 07/10/11

Cabin review: 8G8336

Cabin 8336 had a terribly disruptive sound - as if someone was banging on a gigantic pipe under our room. It lasted a day, and then ended. They said it was due to the jacuzzi above. In addition, you definitely hear the noise from the movement above in the buffet restaurant - Chairs, etc. Other than that, it was fine.

Port and Shore Excursions

Fun boardwalk with shops, restaurants and some street entertainment. Weather here was significantly better than St. John. When our tour was canceled due to lack of interest, we found Murphy's on the boardwalk and organized our own deep sea fishing which was cheaper and practically a private boat since it was us and a few others. They even dropped us off near the cruise terminal, which saved us time on our way back to the boat.

Read 563 Halifax Reviews

Pretty eerie, especially when it's raining and foggy. Desolate - where are the people of St. John?

Even when the entertainment hosts asked the audience if they liked St. John, the crowd was silent. When asking if we liked Halifax, people actually cheered because it was that much more interesting than St. John.

Suggestions, walk around town, check out the old market and cemetery.

Compare Prices on Carnival Glory Canada & New England Cruises

Read more Carnival Glory cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Carnival Glory Review >>

Compare Prices on Carnival Glory Canada & New England Cruises

Member Since 2011
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Carnival Glory deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Carnival Glory 74% Loved It

7 Day Exotic Western Caribbean
See all Carnival Glory Deals >>