Libert of The Seas 3/5-3/13/2011: Liberty of the Seas Cruise Review by ptsnpy

Liberty of the Seas 4
Member Since 2008
228 Forum Posts

Overall Member Rating

Libert of The Seas 3/5-3/13/2011

Sail Date: March 2011
Destination: Southern Caribbean
Embarkation: Miami
We arrived by Southwest Airlines into Ft Lauderdale, caught the GO shuttle to Miami. Very easy to do! $20.00pp, 45 min & It dropped us off right in front of the terminal. Embarkation wasn't as much of a hassle as it had been in other ports, unless you are cruising on Carnival Liberty & you are holding up the security line because you are in the wrong terminal :}. That was all we had to wait on until we got to the front of the line. Our agent seemed a little new, as he was taking a bit longer to process us on & we had our paperwork done. Oh well, we got on. The ship was beautiful! Really loved the touch screens near the elevators. Made it so easy that you didn't have to carry a cruise compass with you.

Dining Room:

Hmmm. Average is all I can say. Nothing stood out. Service was adequate. We had main seating. Took almost 1 hour each night to get appetizers. On the 4Th night, it took 1 15 min for salads. We finally got our main meal & it was wrong. Steak More was cold. We left without eating main course & didn't go back. We opted for the Windjammer the next night. It wasn't fancy, but we got a selection & didn't have to wait.

Windjammer: A little more crowded than usual, but still was able to find seating without much of a problem. Food was ok. Coffee was very hot. Temp could be turned down a bit. We usually had breakfast & lunch. Although we ate dinner twice.

Promenade Cafe:

Cookies all day! What a nice place to catch a mid day snack & people watch. Also great for snack after you left the show. Good place for a light breakfast if you don't want to encounter a lot of people. Coffee was a better temp.

Portofino's: AWESOME!!!!!

Now this was a meal!Service was excellent. Food was way above a 10! We would eat there every night if it didn't have a surcharge or possibly lower charge. But still it wasn't bad for $20.00 pp. We had the T Bone steak. I know what you're thinking. Portofino's is Italian. But the T Bone was truly magnificent. The Cesar salad could feed 3 people for each plate. The desserts... If you don't have room, take it with you! The couple we dined with had Tiramisu. I had Chocolate Mousse, My husband had the sampler. We made him order it so we could all try it. Portofino's is a definite THUMBS UP!


Yes,???? Very poor selection. Gordon the Cruise Director was not of our liking. He seemed to be sold on himself. I don't know if incorporating Dream-works had anything to do with the shows, but if it does, I hope it changes before I book my T/A on the Liberty. We went to the show every night, but we walked out after about 15 min except for 1 show (In The Air). There was a comedian scheduled on a night. Well he wasn't a comedian. He was a violinist. When we asked Gordon where the comedian was his answer was "If I announced he was a Violinist, no-one would come" Well wouldn't that be better than being on stage doing your performance & seeing 1/2 of the guests walk out. That seems a little embarrassing.

I was really disappointed in the low promotion of Make-A-Wish. There was a walk scheduled on our last day. T-shirts were not being sold like they were on the Voyager. We raised over $10,000 on the Voyager in 14 days. They really talked it up. We are with the Central Texas Make-A-Wish. Really disappointed. But this relates back to the Cruise Director. If it's not something you believe in or support, then there's no since in announcing it. This cruise had quite a few kids on it. What an opportunity to get involved.

Cupcake Cupboard was a true disappointment. We were looking forward to this. We didn't want to go on the Oasis to experience it. The cupcakes were cold inside as if they were frozen. That's not a problem. I work in a bakery & we make cakes & freeze them also. The problem is they were dry & had no taste. We got the Red Velvet & the Orange Creamsicle. Don't waste your money.

We will cruise on Liberty again despite the flaws. We are going to book a T/A Westbound in fall 2012. Hopefully there will be a better Cruise Director (bring Mercedes to the Liberty) & the dining room crew & staff will get their timing better to serve meals in the the allotted time correctly. Less

Published 03/14/11

Cabin review: PR6329 Promenade Stateroom

Room: We have always had a balcony room on other cruises, never anything smaller. We opted for a Promenade stateroom this time as our friends we were cruising with had a JS, so we could visit them. We chose the PR from seeing it on cabin crawl in November on the Voyager. (Cabin crawl is an awesome way to see other stateroom categories). We had adequate room. Closet was same as we had in our balcony room prior. The main difference was the bed. It allowed a smaller walking space in the room since the end was only 12 inches from the wall. We really liked the window looking out. It had 2 small seating couches & a chair at the desk. We had plenty of room for 8 days for the 2 of us. The bathroom seemed about the same size. The only drawback we had was where they place the light switch to the bathroom. It is behind the door. The door opens to the room, so if you turn the light on & open the door, it will light up the room & wake everyone up. The room is very dark, so bring a small flashlight to avoid this. We didn't notice any noise that bothered us. You could barely hear any from the promenade. Good location as we were above Guest Services, so noise was minimal.

Read All Promenade Stateroom (PR) Reviews >>

Port and Shore Excursions

San Juan is nice. Seemed a bit crowded in the shopping area. Very narrow streets. We didn't stay long when we found the 2 forts that looked quite a bit more interesting. We went to Fort San Felipe Del Morro. Be prepared to walk! There is a lot to see. We spent 3 hours there & didn't cover it all. Really very interesting history. Cost was $3.00 or you could do both for $5.00 per person. It is part of the National park system so your pass may work if you have it. We will return here & finish our exploring of the forts. It is really interesting seeing where our history is born & lived.

Read 2945 San Juan Reviews

OK this port was way cool. We have decided to take another cruise with this port in the itinerary. We opted to get a taxi ride to Maho beach. Taxi takes about 40 minutes depending on traffic due to the drawbridge. Be sure to fill the taxi so your rate is less. Rates are posted & non negotiable. We paid $8.00 per person each way. Maho Beach is totally cool if you don't mind low flying jumbo jets & blowing sand, We didn't. The jets are literally 50 feet or so above your head as they are coming to the landing strip. When they take off, the jet blast from the plane will throw you in the water if you are in that area. There are signs warning of this. You can sit at Sunset Beach bar & grill & just chill watching the planes. This is a must see excursion. Don't book on the ship as you will only get to stay there 30 min-1hr & may only get to see 1-2 planes. We saw 8 land between 11:30 am & 2:45 pm. There is a beautiful beach to hang out & watch the planes. The water is very beautiful. While you are waiting for planes landing there is a small shopping area about 1/2 mile with several shops.

We didn't spend much time on this port as we opted for the ferry to go to St Johns. Taxi fees are not posted. We spent $10.00 pp & $6.00 Ferry to St Johns. Took about 25 min taxi ride & 20 min ferry ride. Coming back we took the ferry that went back to the Charlotte-Amalie Wharf. This was $11.00 pp & took 45 minutes on the ferry. It was then a 1-1/2 walk back to the ship. But it was a very beautiful walk through the shopping area. We spent most of the day on St Johns just walking the town. We will spend more time on St Thomas on our next cruise & not go to St Johns, since there wasn't much too see. Although it is beautiful & has a National Park on it.

Read 3993 St. Thomas Reviews

Compare Prices on Liberty of the Seas Southern Caribbean Cruises

Read more Liberty of the Seas cruise reviews >>
Read Cruise Critic’s Liberty of the Seas Review >>

Compare Prices on Liberty of the Seas Southern Caribbean Cruises

Member Since 2008
228 Forum Posts
Enrichment Activities
Family & Children
Fitness & Recreation
Onboard Experience
Public Rooms
Shore Excursions
Value for Money
Share feedback
Thank you!  Cruise Critic values your feedback.
How can we improve this page?
Skip X

See Liberty of the Seas deals up to 82% off:

September Deals
Liberty of the Seas 76% Loved It

7 Night Western Caribbean Cruise
See all Liberty of the Seas Deals >>