I honestly don't get all the horrible reviews. What did you guys expect? A $5K/night suite at the Ritz?
Anyway, everybody is entitled to their opinion and no other judgement will be passed on here.
Background: I have traveled with DH, DS (20 mo old), Grandmother and friends (couple with 2 older teenagers) on the 12/18/10 sailing out of NYC. This is my 3rd NCL cruise and let me state that NCL was my least favorite cruise line before this.
Nice location, convenient and easy to find. Less rocking in stormy weather.