I believe my expectations were too high for this cruise. I'll go through the cruise and comment accordingly with letter grades: A-F.
Embarkation: A
The embarkation process was much better than I expected. You drop off your luggage, go through security and get on the boat fairly quickly. I'd say the whole process took about an hour. The lines weren't bad and security was fairly lax. You could easily bring liquor or more than one bottle of wine, as NO ONE checks this.
Beds fold out of the wall, like Murphy beds. Toilet smells, all the time. Room was a nice size for 4 people, maintenance crew is AMAZING!!