DH and I are Platium members with RCl and will be diamond after this cruise. We are very happy with the RCL product and understand cutbacks during the economic times. That being said these are my observations.
Ship: Well maintained and easy to navigate. Yes our stateroom had some stains on the sofa but to expect there to be none with a ship in service 365 days a year is unrealistic. There were plenty of activities for the young and old alike and we were never bored.
Room: Our cabin was AFT cabin 1388. This cabin has been talked about on cruise critic as one of the best for the price and I have to agree. It was the size of a JS without the extra added expense. DH and i spent more time relaxing on our large balcony and in the room than normal because of the extra space.
cabin 1388 is great. Tons of extra space. large balcony with 2 loungers a larger table and chairs. Cabin is the size of a junior suite for the price of an e1