This is my second cruise. The first was on a Disney ship last summer. I do have input from people who've sailed on every cruise line for comparison sake.
The Ship: Good: Common areas are great..especially the Spinnaker Lounge and the Venetian main dining room.
I found myself at the Spinnaker more than one afternoon to get away from the herds at the pool to read and enjoy the panoramic view.
Filthy carpet, nice bathroom, no very few tv channels.