This was our 6th cruise and 6th cruise line. We booked it because the ship (Arvia) was new (and large), but primarily because the itinerary visited a few places we had not been to before. Overall I would rate this as 3.5 out of 5.
The itinerary was 14 days from Bridgetown, Barbados visiting
Road Town, Tortola BVI
We had a balcony cabin right beside the lifts at the back of the ship. The room was spacious, even the bathroom was a reasonable size for a cruise ship. The decor was clean and modern. We had The White Company toiletries, which felt very posh. It is handy to have tea and coffee facilities in the room. The balcony was slightly overlooked by a couple of wider balconies next door, but that just meant we had to pull the curtains from time to time. We never heard the lifts or noticed any additional foot traffic.