This was my first time on the Liberty. I've done both larger and smaller ships and the size was ok, however there are clearly a lot of improvements needed on this ship.
First of all, it was so nice to see everything decorated for the holidays, however the CONSTANT Christmas music, EVEN in the spa was a bit much. There was no escaping it, except for pool side. The Solarium even had it playing non stop.
The overall care of the ship was lacking- the public bathrooms were often messy. The crew was not as friendly as I've seen onsite other ships with a few exceptions. Our cabin steward left us some cute animals and the crew member at the bar/coffee area in the Windjammer always had a smile. And I cannot say enough about the fabulous ladies at the spa!!! While this ship had a free use sauna and steam room available, they were not well kept. I would have rather paid the extra $ for an upgraded thermal suite.
Love having a shower enclosure without that annoying curtain. No tissues in the cabin, we were told they were clogging up toilets!