Overall, a wonderful cruise.
Biggest complaints: they hold their most popular entertainment in small venues where hundreds of people are turned away. The comedians and the rock band specifically. You need to stand in line well over an hour to have any chance of getting a seat. On the other hand, their "stage shows" held in the big Broadway Theatre were not well attended because they were 1) broadway tunes, 2) Latin dancing and 3) 50s hillbilly rock.
Dining was above expectations. Of course you don't get lobster tails anymore, but the complimentary dining was more than satisfactory, with good menu choices and high food quality. Dining room service was excellent.
Club balcony "mini-suite" with extended balcony. Great room, awesome room steward. Great shower, nice balcony, and the bed was comfortable.
Nice place to walk around and shop.
Did the excursion walking up Dunns River Falls. It was great.