• Newsletter
  • Write a Review
  • Boards
  • Deals
  • Find a Cruise
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Cruise Tips

Carnival Magic Review

4.0 / 5.0
Editor Rating
1456 reviews
3 Awards

Cardinal is definitely lacking, time to try a new cruise line!

Review for Carnival Magic to Bermuda
User Avatar
6-10 Cruises • Age 40s

Rating by category

Value for Money
Public Rooms
Fitness & Recreation

Additional details

Sail Date: Sep 2022
French onion soup - Prime Steakhouse
Showtime Theater
From chef - Prime Steakhouse
Lido Deck
Welcome aboard show
Welcome aboard show
Short ribs
Welcome aboard show
Welcome aboard show
Magic lobby
Tropical fruit plate - Prime Steakhouse
Welcome aboard show
Welcome aboard show
Shrimp Cocktail - Northern Lights Restaurant
Grilled Shrimp - Northern Lights Restaurant
Showtime Theatre
Roll - Prime Steakhouse
Caesar Salad - Northern Lights Restaurant
Northern Lights Restaurant
Magic lobby
Towel fun
Northern Lights Restaurant
Towel fun
Magic lobby
Towel fun
Banana Crème Pie - Sea Day Brunch - Southern Lights Restaurant
Magic Lobby
Northern Lights Restaurant
Cruise Director Ryan Rose - Amazing
Peach Soup - Northern Lights Restaurant
Tropical Fruit Plate - Northern Lights Restaurant
Magic lobby
Ship at Manhattan Terminal
Filet Mignon with Béarnaise Sauce and Max & Cheese - Prime Steakhouse
Serenity Deck
Magic lobby
Strawberry Soup - Northern Lights Restaurant
Margherita Pizza - Pizzeria Del Capitano
Ship at night in Bermuda
Magic lobby
Towel fun
Lido Deck and water park
Shrimp cocktail - Prime Steakhouse
Magic Lobby
Lido Deck Mid pool
From chef - Prime steakhouse
Magic lobby
Magic lobby
Caprese - Northern Lights Restaurant
Lido Deck
Sea day breakfast - Southern Lights Restaurant

Carnival Cruise Line is known as the Fun Ships and they definitely are fun! This was my 7th Carnival Cruise and 9th overall cruise.

We boarded the Carnival Magic in Manhattan New York. The boarding process was pretty easy and very organized. The only problem with Manhattan Terminal is that they do not let you wait anywhere, so you have to arrive on time and depart quickly.

For those of you that have not cruised before, let me explain the process briefly. You check in prior to the cruise and get a time to check in at the terminal. You are given a 30 minute window and should you miss it, it’s ok but you may have a longer wait. There are porters at the terminal to take your checked luggage. Don’t forget to tip them or your luggage may get misplaced or lost. For 2022 the average tip is $1 a bag but I feel it should be about $2 a bag. You then proceed to into the terminal and get in line to check in. Remember to have your passport, boarding pass, Covid 19 test results and any additional paperwork you may need depending on your port if call. Bermuda requires a waiver that has to be paid ($40) for prior to your cruise along with a negative Covid 19 test within 2 days of the cruise. Carnival also requires all guests to be vaccinated and a Covid test within 3 days of cruising. During check in, they take your photo, check your documents and then you move on to security to get your bags checked as well as yourself. From there, when your section is called you board the ship! Rooms are not ready till around 1:30pm but you can go to your room and drop your carry on luggage off. Head up to the Lido deck and grab some lunch.

Cabin Review

Cabin was nice but very dusty. Balcony was enjoyable! We were 3 to this cabin and it worked out perfectly! Bent took very good care of us!

Port Reviews

Bermuda is absolutely beautiful! My first trip here I was only here for a day and went to Horseshoe Bay Beach. This time I was here for 2 full nights!

The first day I did the full island tour which was amazing! Our Tour guide was Samuel and he was the best! A Bermuda native that gave us so much information while we toured the island. Educational and loaded with tips to save you money and ways to go around the island on your own.

We toured, Hamilton, St George’s, the beaches, bridges, Gibbs Hill Lighthouse, where you were given time to climb the lighthouse, and more. It was one of the best tours I have ever been on! I highly recommend it. $85 through shipmate and completely worth it! 5+ hours long!

At night we did the Glassbottom boat coral reef and ship wreck tour which I purchased through Carnival and it was horrible. The coral reef is very blah looking and the shipwreck was a joke. It’s a piece about the size of your pinky finger from tip to knuckle sticking out of the water and you only see it because the water is splashing up it. Nothing else is seen in the water. The water was so murky due to the recent Fiona storm that hit and the excursion really should have been cancelled. Totally not worth the $80 that it cost! It was 90 minutes and included a Rum Swizzle that we couldn’t taste much alcohol in at all.

Very expensive country but so beautiful. The pink sands are so soft. The water is gorgeous! The coral reef, rather blah!

5 Helpful Votes
previous reviewnext review

Find a Carnival Magic Cruise from $329

Any Month
Want to cruise smarter?
Get expert advice, insider tips and more.
By proceeding, you agree to Cruise Critic’s Privacy and Cookies Statement and Terms of Use.
About UsCruise DestinationsFirst Time CruisersFind A Cruise

Share your feedback

International Sites

© 1995—2023, The Independent Traveler, Inc.

  • Privacy and Cookies Statement

  • Terms of Use

  • Site Map

  • Cookie Consent