We sailed recently with two other couples. We've never been on this size of RC ship and after being on the Anthem and Harmony, were worried we would be disappointed. Nothing could be further from the truth. This is a cozy, older ship with lots of character and probably the best staff we've met. Yes you will find some rust and there are areas that need to be updated but none of those things affected our experience.
We ate most dinners in the main dining room and the food was very good. We also ate in Chops and Giovanni's Table. Chops was the winner for us. We had dinner on the first night in the Windjammer as we couldn't get a table for over an hour in the dining room. Not a huge deal but we were hungry. I really wish they could fine tune the "My Time Dining" to be more flexible. Even with a reservation, there were nights we had to wait.
Our stateroom, 7650, is a good hike to the elevators but well taken care of and our stateroom attendance, Sagar, was wonderful. I'm surprised how much storage a small cabin has. There were cabinets we didn't even use.