We really like the quiet atmosphere of Oceanic - very few children, not a lot of loud music. The pool area stays relatively quiet.
The food is, for the most part, very good - especially in the specialty restaurants. We had the wine and beer package, which allows beer and wine by the glass at meals. It was adequate. I would suggest they add a couple of WBTG at each restaurant to complement the food.
Our cabin was wonderful - Penthouse Suite. Roomy and comfortable. Rahul the butler and Danelia the housekeeper were friendly and efficient. You get hors d-ouvrves each afternoon, which was nice, but they weren't great. The only noise from above was late at night, and it was minor.
Really nice - comfortable bed, large balcony, good storage, ample bathroom. The only thing I would add are more accessible outlets for hairdryers. There is not one in the bathroom, and the only other one is under the TV. Kind of inconvenient. Lots of nice perks such as free laundry, canapes, etc.