I choose this cruise to see fall colors and visit the Maine and Canadian ports, which were great. The cruise on the other had was not great for me. It was far too large of a ship, very crowded, and there were virtually no quiet spaces other than on our stateroom deck. I felt like I was trapped in a casino/shopping mall/disco, with far too many people.
Positives: a great gym, with great staff. Excellent ports and shore excursions. Ship seemed entirely safe. Variety of food was great, and most of it was good considering they were feeding 4K+ a day.
Negatives: